Week 2 of the NFL season gave us a clearer look at the 2025 rookie class, and several first-year players are already proving they belong. According to PFSN’s grading dashboard, a handful of rookies stood out with high-impact performances, earning spots on PFSN’s All-Rookie Team.
Here’s a full breakdown of each player, their grade, and what made their Week 2 performance special.
QB: Cam Ward, TEN — 69.3 (D+)
Cam Ward was the only rookie quarterback to qualify this week, and while his 69.3 grade isn’t eye-popping, it marked an improvement from his Week 1 score of 63.7. He ranked 28th among all QBs in Week 2, and the biggest issue continues to be pressure. Ward is averaging -0.59 EPA per drop-back when pressured, which ranks 28 out of 34 qualifying quarterbacks.
The film never lied on Cam Ward. His game was always going to translate.
He’s only going to get better. pic.twitter.com/tSSsuvdWwX
— Kurt Benkert (@KurtBenkert) September 14, 2025
The Tennessee Titans are asking a lot of him early, and while the flashes are there, he’ll need cleaner pockets to grow.
RB: Cam Skattebo, NYG — 75.8 (C)
Cam Skattebo was one of the three qualifying rookie backs this week, and he made the most of his touches. He logged 11 carries for 45 yards and a touchdown, with nearly all of that production coming after contact. His 3.2 yards after contact per rush ranked 11 among 33 RBs, showing off his physicality and balance.
He’s not a burner, but he runs angry, and that’s earning him more trust in the New York Giants backfield rotation.
WR: Tetairoa McMillan, CAR — 79.2 (C+)
Tetairoa McMillan continues to be one of the most efficient rookie receivers in the league. He posted 10.0 yards per target, tying Puka Nacua and ranking 24 out of 87 qualifiers. More impressively, he’s accounted for 35% of the Carolina Panthers’ total receiving yards, the tenth-highest share among all NFL wideouts.
Tetairoa McMillan is a freak show. Buy stock now. pic.twitter.com/aCFDX56jyU
— Ethan Young (@EthanYoungFB) September 15, 2025
He’s not just producing, he’s becoming a go-to weapon for quarterback Bryce Young.
TE: Tyler Warren, IND — 82.5 (B-)
Tyler Warren was a breakout performer in Week 2, ranking fourth among all tight ends regardless of experience. He generated 36.9 yards after catch over expected, second only to Tucker Kraft (39.8).
Warren’s blend of size and fluidity makes him a matchup problem, and he’s quickly emerging as a reliable target in the Indianapolis Colts evolving offense.
OT: Anthony Beltron, GB — 76.3 (C)
Anthony Belton stepped in at right tackle for the Green Bay Packers with Zach Tom sidelined, and he delivered a clean sheet: zero pressures allowed on 25 pass-blocking snaps. That kind of poise from a rookie in spot duty is rare.
Belton’s footwork and anchor held up well, and he may have earned himself more reps going forward.
IOL: Dylan Fairchild, CIN — 79.3 (C+)
Dylan Fairchild bounced back in a big way after a rough debut. In Week 1, he allowed four pressures on 29 pass-blocking snaps. In Week 2, he allowed zero pressures on 48 snaps. That’s a massive turnaround, and it speaks to his ability to adjust quickly.
The Cincinnati Bengals’ interior line has been shaky, but Fairchild might be a stabilizer.
DT: Jamaree Caldwell, LAC — 77.7 (C+)
Jamaree Caldwell was disruptive in limited action, generating four pressures on just 21 pass rush snaps. He also recorded his first career sack, a clutch third-down stop in the red zone that forced the Las Vegas Raiders to settle for a field goal.
Caldwell’s burst and leverage are translating early, and he’s flashing starter upside.
EDGE: Mykel Williams, SF — 81.7 (B-)
Mykel Williams played a hybrid role, lining up 57% of the time on the edge and 43% on the interior. He posted three pressures, two tackles for loss, and helped hold the New Orleans Saints to -0.25 yards per carry on his run stops.
He’s already showing positional versatility, and with Nick Bosa earning the highest EDGE grade of the week (91.1), San Francisco’s front looks terrifying.
LB: Jihaad Campbell, PHI — 75.1 (C)
Jihaad Campbell was everywhere. He recorded seven tackles without a miss, allowed just a 56.3 passer rating on three targets in coverage, and even generated a pressure. His EDGE snaps doubled from six in Week 1 to 12 in Week 2, showing the Philadelphia Eagles are expanding his role.
OUTSTANDING play by rookie LB Jihaad Campbell pic.twitter.com/vFVowtiMXd
— Warren Sharp (@SharpFootball) September 5, 2025
He’s instinctive and fast, and he’s earning trust.
CB: Trey Amos, WAS — 83.7 (B)
Trey Amos was lockdown in coverage. He allowed just two catches for 14 yards on four targets, with a 41.7 QB rating against and a pass breakup. His 0.6 yards per coverage snap ranked among the best in the league.
The Washington Commanders’ secondary has struggled, but Amos looks like a long-term solution.
S: Malaki Starks, BAL — 80.5 (B-)
Malaki Starks was targeted six times and allowed four catches, but only for 32 yards. That’s a 79.9 QB rating against, and he added five tackles without a miss.
His range and tackling discipline are already NFL-caliber, and the Baltimore Ravens’ secondary looks sharper with him in the mix.
These rookies didn’t just flash; they executed. Whether it was McMillan’s efficiency, Skattebo’s toughness, or Warren’s YAC explosion, Week 2 showed that this class is deeper than advertised.
