Jalen Tolbert, South Alabama WR | NFL Draft Scouting Report

As his scouting report shows, South Alabama WR Jalen Tolbert has the physical and mental tools to be a top NFL Draft prospect in 2022.

South Alabama WR Jalen Tolbert was a dominant force in Sun Belt play, but how does his NFL Draft scouting report translate to the professional game? In a deep, well-stocked wide receiver class, Tolbert is sometimes overlooked. But wherever he goes in the NFL Draft, Tolbert may just have the tools to produce in the years to come. Here’s a look at what Tolbert offers and where he might hear his name called on draft night.

Jalen Tolbert NFL Draft Profile

  • Position: Wide Receiver
  • School: South Alabama
  • Current Year: Redshirt Senior
  • Height: 6’1 1/8″
  • Weight: 194 pounds
  • Wingspan: 76 3/8″
  • Length: 32 1/4″
  • Hand: 10″

Tolbert’s Combine/pro day results

  • 40-Yard Dash: 4.49
  • Broad Jump: 10’3″
  • Vertical Jump: 36″
  • Three-Cone: 7.08
  • Short Shuttle: 4.24

Jalen Tolbert Scouting Report

Tolbert became a star early at South Alabama, with leaping grabs and awe-inspiring body control in midair. A big-play factory for the Jaguars, passes were constantly funneled in Tolbert’s direction. It’s rare that one skill-position player dictates an entire offensive attack and keeps the engine running. But Tolbert did that for South Alabama during his time there.

Now, however, Tolbert’s collegiate career is over. And as productive as he was for the Jaguars, there’s a question that looms over him. Is his production, which was largely attained against Sun Belt defenders, translatable to the next level, where he’ll compete for playing time against NFL receivers and for possession against NFL cornerbacks? That’s a question we’ll explore in this scouting report.

Tolbert’s athletic profile

The dynamics of WR/CB battles are incredibly complex. But one trait that matters in any situation is athleticism. Athletic players can simply do more, and Tolbert fits this description. Tolbert has a long, lean, and compact frame at 6’1 1/4″, 195 pounds. His 32-inch arms give him a good catch radius, but he’s also an impressive mover for his size.

Tolbert has excellent twitch and suddenness off the line. He can stack crisp feet motions to earn early separation, employing short bursts of energy in rapid succession. The South Alabama WR possesses a great deal of potential energy as a lateral mover, and he creates displacement with ease.

In short areas, Tolbert is exciting. He also shows pronounced upside in space. Tolbert has strong explosiveness when he has a runway, and he has terrific long speed for his size. He uses this long speed to stack defensive backs and gain leverage downfield. And with the ball in his hands, he flashes slippery run-after-catch ability.

Tolbert’s athleticism also shows up at the catch point. He adjusts to inaccurate passes with exceptional quickness. Additionally, the South Alabama WR has shown off stellar body control and acrobatic ball-tracking ability on more than one occasion.

Execution beyond the physical traits

Tolbert’s game wouldn’t be the same without his combination of size and speed. Nevertheless, the South Alabama WR enriches his scouting report with impressive executional traits as well. This shows up most often in his route running, where he has the capacity to be brisk, detailed, and unpredictable.

Tolbert is a fairly methodical route runner who knows how to exploit defenders and break free. His footwork is strong, and he’s shown he can use a multitude of releases at the line, including a dead leg move to manipulate spacing. Tolbert also uses head fakes to manipulate leverage against cornerbacks and displays situational awareness ahead of route stems.

Down the field, Tolbert’s strengths continue to rack up. The South Alabama WR can separate in the intermediate and deep ranges with quick, savvy double moves. He also has an understanding of leverage in this realm. At the catch point, Tolbert can use his frame to box out defenders in tight situations. He proactively uses his 32″ arms to extend his catching radius and actively guides the ball in with his hands.

Among other things, Tolbert can gather the ball without losing any speed in RAC situations. Moreover, he brings an attitude on the field — a necessary component for mental warfare on the boundary.

Areas for improvement

Tolbert is one of college football’s best receivers heading into 2021, but if he wants to lock down early-round status, these are the things he needs to work on. Most notably, Tolbert could continue to refine his route running and play to his physical maximum more consistently.

Tolbert is a good route runner as it is, but he could afford to sink his hips more during direction changes to maximize efficiency. His lacking hip sink sometimes inhibits his freedom of motion, especially on in-breaking routes. He’s shown to have the capacity to sink his hips, but he needs to be more consistent.

Additionally, Tolbert rounds off his route breaks at times. But conversely, he also overthinks his routes and plays into the defender’s leverage with his lateral quickness. Going further, Tolbert can better employ physicality in conjunction with his footwork and twitch. His lateral mobility gives him some utility against press coverage, but he’ll need to be more proactive and physical at the NFL level.

Continuing with areas for improvement, Tolbert can sometimes be susceptible to focus drops. Although he has great contested-catch ability, his hands aren’t always as strong or consistent as desired, and his technique can improve. He’s also not a great run blocker, and there are times where his energy drops when he’s not getting the ball.

Tolbert’s NFL Draft scouting report overview

Coming into 2021 as a redshirt senior and set to be a 23-year-old rookie, Tolbert still has a few areas to refine in his game. Minimizing focus drops will be an important task this year, as will further perfecting his route running. Nevertheless, looking at his profile as a whole, all of his negatives are minor. Meanwhile, his mix of athleticism, size, and three-level ability makes him an incredibly exciting player.

The entire Pro Football Network staff is high on Tolbert, but none more so than Cam Mellor, who had the following to say about the South Alabama WR:

“[Jalen] Tolbert is the prototypical wide receiver for any NFL offense in 2021 and beyond. He creates separation pre-snap with his eyes and understanding of defenses just as he creates separation from defenders with routes. He has tremendous straight-line speed for his size yet doesn’t lose speed in his cuts. He’s a dependable YAC threat with terrific hands who is an exceptional high-pointer of the football. He’s the total package outside.”

I’m not quite as high on Tolbert as Mellor, but I understand the appeal. Although I believe his hands can still be more consistent, there’s nothing to suggest he can’t be a quality NFL receiver. Tolbert’s 2021 season was more of a lateral move than a step up. But heading into 2021, Tolbert was already a respectable prospect. He’ll have fans in the NFL, and a strong Senior Bowl and Combine showing could help him sneak into the Day 2 range.

Tolbert’s Player Profile

Tolbert has worked for everything he’s gotten, and there’s no better proof of that than where he began. A product of Mobile, Alabama, Tolbert was unranked on ESPN’s 2017 recruiting board. He was ranked on 247 Sports but only esteemed as a two-star recruit.

Despite his low rating, Tolbert earned offers from an assortment of schools. He originally committed to Jacksonville State early in his recruiting cycle but reopened his recruitment when teams like Ball State, Massachusetts, Vanderbilt, and Michigan State showed interest.

Those offers, however, weren’t enough to sway Tolbert from his hometown team — the South Alabama Jaguars.

His career at South Alabama

Tolbert was set to see the field as a true freshman, but the South Alabama WR suffered a season-ending knee injury in his opening scrimmage. He’d ultimately be sidelined until 2018. Tolbert then had to reset as a redshirt freshman, still needing to acclimate to the college game.

2018 was just that — a year of acclimation. Tolbert only caught 5 passes, but his experience that season helped set up a much more productive 2019 campaign. In 2019, Tolbert started in all 12 games, amassing 27 catches for 521 yards and 6 touchdowns. It was a drastic leap in production. However, it would pale in comparison to his 2020 showing.

Last year, Tolbert was borderline dominant in the Sun Belt Conference. He accounted for approximately 40% of his team’s receiving production, accumulating 1,085 yards and 8 touchdowns on 64 receptions. He was a first-team All-Sun Belt selection for his play and placed on the Biletnikoff Award watch list for the 2021 season.

Tolbert’s NFL Draft ascension

By now, Tolbert is an established presence. He’s a legitimate 2022 NFL Draft prospect, and his offseason has only reinforced his stock. But even after a strong Senior Bowl and Combine, don’t expect Tolbert to stop just because of how far he’s come.

His work ethic is renowned, and that’s become clear even to offensive coordinator Major Applewhite, who was hired late last year. In Applewhite’s own words, courtesy of Pro Football Network’s Cam Mellor:

“What a joy it is to work with Jalen [Tolbert]. Day in and day out, he has a smile on his face to go along with an incredible work ethic. He is always trying to learn more about the layers and details of what you are doing. Obviously, his skill set speaks for itself, but he has opened himself up to coaching from coach Michael Smith — who has coached a lot of great wide receivers — and continued to learn every day.”

The work isn’t done for Tolbert, but that isn’t lost on him. Refusing to rest on his laurels, Tolbert has a chance to become a playmaker at the NFL level. He may be more of a rotational receiver early on, but he has the athletic traits and the well-rounded profile to become more.

Ian Cummings is a Draft Analyst for Pro Football Network. You can find his writing here and follow him on Twitter: @ian_cummings_9