The revelation sheds light on just how close the Cowboys icon came to suiting up for one of their fiercest rivals. It also offers a fascinating glimpse into the chaos that can unfold during an NFL season when injuries strike. Now, Aikman has shared the full story behind a surprising call that almost changed everything.
Troy Aikman Recalls Andy Reid’s Pitch to Join the Eagles During a Halftime Call
Speaking on the “New Heights” podcast, Aikman detailed the bizarre sequence of events that unfolded during a 2002 broadcast, shortly after he had transitioned into his media career. At the time, he was working a game in San Diego when news broke that Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb had suffered a broken fibula.
Aikman and his fellow broadcasters covered the injury during the game, and he assumed that would be the extent of his involvement. However, things quickly took an unexpected turn when his producer approached him during halftime.
“We’re getting ready to go to halftime, and my producer says, ‘Hey, I’ve got a number that I need you to call at halftime,’ which he had never done. I was in my third year broadcasting, in the middle of a broadcast, trying to call from the booth at halftime, and there’s no cell service,” said Aikman
Determined to make the call, Aikman stepped out into the stadium concourse, navigating through fans while trying to connect.
“So I walk out onto the concourse — this was the old Jack Murphy Stadium — and fans are walking by yelling at me. I get Andy Reid on the phone,” said Aikman.
On the other end of the line was then Eagles head coach Andy Reid, who wasted little time getting to the point. With McNabb sidelined, Philadelphia was suddenly in need of a QB, and Reid had a clear name in his mind.
“He said, ‘Hey it’s Andy.’ I said, ‘Andy Reid?’ He says ‘You heard what happened [to McNabb] didn’t you?’ I said ‘Yeah, we just did a game break on it.’ He says ‘Well, I wanna talk to you.’ I said ‘Andy, I’m in the middle of a broadcast.’ And he says ‘I know you are. I need you to call me after the game,'” Aikman explained.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
This is where things get interesting. “So I called him after the game and he was selling me on why I should come out of retirement and go sign with the Eagles and play for them. They were playing Monday night, the next game was against the 49ers. Obviously I didn’t do it.” Aikman added.
Imagine the idea of Aikman, a lifelong Cowboy, joining the Eagles would have been unthinkable for many fans. Ultimately, he declined the opportunity, and in hindsight, the decision worked out well for Philadelphia.
Backup quarterback A.J. Feeley stepped in and led the team to five straight wins, helping stabilize the season until McNabb returned for the playoffs. The Eagles eventually advanced to the NFC Championship Game that year.
While Aikman’s playing days were defined by championship success, the Cowboys’ recent performance tells a different story. In the 2025 season, Dallas finished with a 7-9-1 record despite boasting a strong offense.
According to PFSN’s Offense Impact Metrics, the Cowboys posted an 84.8 OFFi score, ranking sixth in the league with a B grade, highlighting their offensive efficiency. However, defensive struggles proved costly, as they recorded a 62.1 DEFi score on PFSN’s Defense Impact Metrics, ranking last in the league and impacting their overall results.
Looking back, Aikman’s near-return serves as one of the more fascinating “what-if” moments in NFL history. While he ultimately stayed retired, the story underscores how quickly circumstances can shift in the league — and how even the most unlikely scenarios can briefly become like Philip Rivers reality.
