Five years ago, when Kyle Pitts walked across the draft stage, it felt less like a selection and more like a coronation. The Atlanta Falcons made him the highest-drafted tight end in NFL history, and the expectation was immediate: this was the next great one. The unicorn. The mismatch nightmare. The future. And yet, football, like most good stories, rarely follows the script.
Why the Chiefs Make Sense for Kyle Pitts as the Eventual Replacement for Travis Kelce
Now, after a career that has been more slow burn than instant classic, Pitts is coming off a second-team All-Pro season and staring at free agency with something he hasn’t always had: leverage.
Meanwhile, the Kansas City Chiefs are quietly bracing for life after Travis Kelce. Which is how we come to the storyline that feels almost too narratively perfect: a 15-touchdown All-Pro tight end potentially coming into the orbit of Patrick Mahomes as the heir of the apparent legend.
In Kansas City, Kelce has been more than a TE. He’s been a constant. A third-down inevitability. But as he is 36 and openly operates on a year-to-year timeline, the Chiefs are confronting an uncomfortable truth: even dynasties age.
DRAFT SEASON: PFSN’s FREE Mock Draft Simulator
And when they do, they either evolve or they fracture. Pitts, at 25, represents evolution.
After years of uneven quarterback play and shifting offensive identities in Atlanta, Pitts finally looked like the player scouts swore he’d become. In 2025, he hauled in 88 receptions for 928 yards and 5 touchdowns, earning second-team All-Pro honors and finishing eighth in PFSN’s Tight End Impact metric (TEi). Pitts not only was catching passes, but he was also dictating coverage. Drawing safety help.
And that is where the Chiefs start to make sense, according to PFSN.
Andy Reid has long treated the tight end position like a featured character rather than a supporting role. Kelce wasn’t simply productive in Kansas City; he was curated. Deployed in motion. Split wide. Fed in high-leverage moments. Pitts, with his receiver-like fluidity in a 6-foot-6 frame, feels almost purpose-built for that kind of imagination.
Pair him with Mahomes, the most improvisational quarterback in the NFL, and suddenly you are not talking about a replacement. You’re talking about a reimagining.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s FREE Ultimate GM Simulator
In February, Kansas City sits roughly $58 million over the salary cap. Mahomes carries a $78 million cap hit. Chris Jones accounts for $45 million. Adding Pitts, whether via free agency or trade, would require financial choreography bordering on performance art.
Atlanta can franchise tag Pitts at an estimated $16 million for 2026, and if he hits the open market, he could command serious money. After all, last offseason the Dallas Cowboys gave tight end Jake Ferguson a four-year, $50 million extension.
