Philadelphia’s receiving duo enters a crucial Black Friday matchup with contrasting season narratives. A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith both seek more consistent production in an offense that has limited opportunities through the air. Which Eagles receiver warrants fantasy football trust for Week 13?
A.J. Brown’s Fantasy Outlook
Brown has endured a frustrating campaign defined by inconsistency and game-plan limitations. He has accumulated more games with single-digit fantasy points (five) than contests exceeding 12 fantasy points (four). Only three games have featured the ceiling performances managers expected when drafting him as an elite WR1.
Last week provided a glimpse of his upside against Dallas. Brown caught eight passes on 10 targets for 110 yards and a touchdown, delivering his third 20-plus fantasy point performance of the season. The outing reminded fantasy managers why they invested premium draft capital in the vocal receiver who hasn’t been shy about expressing his frustrations with the offense.
MORE: Free Fantasy Football Start/Sit Optimizer
Brown maintains his status as the clear WR1 in Philadelphia’s passing attack. Jalen Hurts attempted 39 passes against the Cowboys, completing 27 for 289 yards. That represented a season-high in volume for the Eagles’ passing game, creating the conditions where Brown thrives as the primary outside target.
His production remains heavily dependent on game script and offensive game plan. The Eagles have leaned extensively on Saquon Barkley and the rushing attack for most of the season, limiting Brown’s weekly opportunity. When Philadelphia commits to throwing, Brown produces WR1 numbers. When they don’t, he disappears entirely from fantasy relevance.
DeVonta Smith’s Fantasy Outlook
Smith has provided a slightly higher floor than his counterpart despite facing similar game-plan constraints. He has reached 14-plus fantasy points in six games this season, offering more consistent weekly production than Brown’s boom-or-bust profile. Smith’s deeper average depth of target has helped him capitalize on defenses focusing their attention on Brown.
The disaster performances still materialize periodically. Smith caught just one pass for eight yards on five targets against Detroit. Those single-digit catastrophes tank fantasy lineups when they occur, though they’ve been less frequent than Brown’s struggles.
READ MORE: Soppe’s Week 13 Fantasy Football Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Analysis for Every Player in Every Game
He bounced back admirably last week with six receptions on 11 targets for 89 yards against Dallas. Smith took several brutal hits during the contest, including an awkward flip and landing following a 41-yard reception in the second quarter. The physical toll resulted in shoulder and chest injuries that kept him out of practice Wednesday and Thursday.
Fortunately, the diminutive receiver not only practiced in full on Friday, but doesn’t even take an injury designation into today’s game.
Should You Start Brown or Smith This Week?
Chicago presents a formidable challenge for Philadelphia’s passing attack on Black Friday. The Bears allow the seventh-most schedule adjusted fantasy points per game to wide receivers, but they’ve also been decimated on defense. Their secondary situation has improved dramatically heading into Week 13.
Chicago activated cornerbacks Jaylon Johnson and Kyler Gordon from injured reserve after both missed extended time. Johnson underwent core muscle surgery while Gordon battled groin and calf injuries. Their return strengthens a unit that was depleted by injuries over recent weeks.
Game environment factors work against passing volume expectations. Philadelphia opened as 7-point favorites with the total set at 44.5 points. The Eagles suffered a devastating collapse against Dallas last week, blowing a 21-0 second-half lead in their 24-21 loss. Teams typically adjust their approach following negative outcomes, often reverting to more conservative strategies.
Hurts attempted 39 passes in the loss to the Cowboys. With projected positive game script against an 8-3 Bears team playing on short rest, Philadelphia figures to lean heavily on Barkley and the ground attack. Hurts likely won’t exceed 30 pass attempts barring them unexpectedly falling behind, inherently limiting what both receivers can accomplish statistically.
Fantasy managers must start both Brown and Smith despite the concerns. Their talent levels remain too elite to bench regardless of matchup or game-script projections. However, expectations should be tempered compared to last week’s production. Neither receiver projects as a weekly league-winner in this spot, though both maintain WR2/WR3 floors through their target shares when active.