The Saturday morning ritual has become unmissable television. Pat McAfee steps up to the microphone, calls out a college student from the crowd, and offers life-changing money for one successful kick. This weekly tradition on College GameDay has turned into must-see drama, with McAfee pulling cash straight from his own pocket and occasionally volunteering Kirk Herbstreit’s wallet without asking first.
How Does Pat McAfee Keep Surprising Kirk Herbstreit With His Own Money?
McAfee’s generosity has reached eye-popping levels this season. Already, two college students have drilled 33-yard field goals during the McAfee Kicking Contest on ESPN’s College GameDay, walking away with payouts between $250,000 and $600,000. The segment combines live drama with massive financial stakes, creating one of the show’s most talked-about moments each week.
With such substantial rewards and an increasing success rate, some viewers have questioned whether McAfee actually delivers the promised money. However, Herbstreit quickly shut down that speculation during his Friday appearance on the “Stugotz and Company” podcast.
“He’s given over $500,000,” Herbstreit confirmed. “People are like, ‘ESPN does that, right?’ I’m like, I know he makes a lot of money, but he’s writing checks to these guys. It’s cool.”
View this post on Instagram
Herbstreit, who holds each attempt, also discussed the contest’s growing popularity on SI Media with Jimmy Traina, describing it as appointment television. The segment has delivered instant classic moments this season, with Ohio State and Oklahoma students converting their kicks in consecutive weeks.
What Happens When McAfee Volunteers Herbstreit’s Money Without Warning?
The most entertaining twist comes when McAfee spontaneously commits Herbstreit to financial contributions. Last week’s episode provided another perfect example, with McAfee announcing the prize money for a successful kick, then casually adding another $100,000 from Herbstreit’s pocket.
This surprise announcement caught Herbstreit completely off guard, as he explained on the podcast. “By the way, how about how Pat sometimes, I don’t even know he’s doing this, he’s like, ‘You know what? Hey, and Kirk’s going to throw in $200,000 over here, too.'”
Herbstreit’s response was definitive when asked whether McAfee gives him advance notice of these financial commitments. “No, never,” Herbstreit said. “He just does that. Last year, he did that to me somewhere. I had to give $100,000 away. It was amazing.”
McAfee quickly responded to Herbstreit’s podcast comments, providing his perspective on the spontaneous money offers and adding to their ongoing friendly banter.
Kirk donated $100,000 to help with Hurricane Relief last year… almost had to put up $400,000 at the SEC Championship with Lisan al-Gaib!!
I have a completely blank check in my mind walking out there.. the number comes strictly from vibes. If Herby starts to talk a little… pic.twitter.com/S7q22tx5y1
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) September 25, 2025
Adding another layer of entertainment, Herbstreit revealed he’s established a 3.5 over/under for successful kicks this season.
With two students already converting their attempts, he’s anticipating one or two more successful kicks before the season ends. College football fans will undoubtedly keep watching closely, waiting to see if another student beats the odds and forces both hosts to reach for their wallets once again.
