The college football world is furious after reports revealed the Big Ten is exploring a radical postseason expansion that would balloon the College Football Playoff to as many as 28 teams. The proposal has fans seeing red, with many blasting it as nothing more than a money grab that would destroy the sport’s competitive integrity.
How Far Is the Big Ten Willing to Push College Football Playoff Expansion?
Pete Thamel of ESPN broke the bombshell news that sent shockwaves through college football. The Big Ten has quietly begun exploring playoff formats that would dwarf the current 12-team system.
“Sources: The Big Ten has begun populating an expanded College Football Playoff idea, which could include 24 or 28 teams. Just an idea at this point,” Thamel reported.
Sources: The Big Ten has begun populating an expanded College Football Playoff idea, which could include 24 or 28 teams. Just an idea at this point. pic.twitter.com/0NlTQ1BN8F
— Pete Thamel (@PeteThamel) August 16, 2025
One of the most audacious versions being discussed would hand seven automatic bids each to the SEC and Big Ten, while the ACC and Big 12 would receive five apiece. The remaining spots would go to two Group of Five programs plus two at-large selections.
This dramatic restructuring would also eliminate conference championship games entirely, fundamentally altering how college football crowns its champion.
Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti reportedly presented these concepts to his conference earlier this week. While no formal proposal exists, the mere suggestion has triggered an avalanche of criticism from fans who see the move as prioritizing profit over the sport itself.
Why Are College Football Fans Calling This Expansion “Stupid”?
The fan reaction has been swift and brutal. Social media exploded with criticism as college football supporters made their feelings crystal clear about the proposed expansion.
One fan blasted the suggestion, saying, “Awful idea 12 teams is already too much leave the playoffs alone.”
“$$$$. Only reason,” another blasted.
A third user responded more bluntly, writing, “Yeah, a really stupid idea.”
Worst idea EVER.
— Alex Hilton ن (@AEHiltonIII) August 16, 2025
The criticism continued to pour in as fans voiced concerns about what this expansion would mean for the sport. “Dumb,” another quipped.
Others worried about the practical implications for players. “If your season starts being 20 games, players heading into the draft arent gonna play,” another fan said.
A joke. 12 is already too many. 💰💰💰💰
— Algernon Smith, M.Ed (@professorsmith2) August 16, 2025
The proposed format would place 20 playoff games on campus sites, building on what many considered the successful opening-round matchups during last season’s CFP.
However, fans clearly believe the expansion goes too far, with many viewing it as diluting the regular season’s importance while extending an already lengthy postseason.
What Does This Mean for the Future of College Football’s Postseason?
The timing of these discussions makes them particularly controversial. The 2025 season marks just the second year of the 12-team playoff system, which was implemented after extensive debate and compromise among conferences and administrators.
Ross Dellenger of Yahoo Sports confirmed the scope of the conversations, reporting, “Multiple 20+ team CFP models are under discussion, deriving from Big Ten, sources tell @YahooSports, as ESPN reported. They feature as many as 7 AQs for each SEC/B1G, 5 ACC/B12, 2 G6 & 2 at-large. Discussions are very early. Could trigger conference title game eliminations.”
Multiple 20+ team CFP models are under discussion, deriving from Big Ten, sources tell @YahooSports, as ESPN reported. They feature as many as 7 AQs for each SEC/B1G, 5 ACC/B12, 2 G6 & 2 at-large.
Discussions are very early. Could trigger conference title game eliminations.
— Ross Dellenger (@RossDellenger) August 16, 2025
College football officials had already been exploring a 16-team expansion, but disagreements over automatic bids and at-large berths have stalled those discussions. The Big Ten’s proposal leapfrogs those conversations entirely, suggesting formats that would nearly triple the current playoff field.
The appeal is obvious for administrators. Expanding to 24 or 28 teams would dramatically increase television inventory, ticket sales, and media rights revenue. The recent 12-team playoff showcased compelling matchups that drew massive audiences, culminating in Ohio State’s national championship run.
MORE READING: Why Is NCAA Facing Backlash for Week 0 Game Between Iowa State and Kansas State?
However, the immediate fan backlash suggests the Big Ten may have overplayed its hand. Critics argue that such massive expansion would render the regular season meaningless while creating a postseason that resembles March Madness more than college football’s traditional format.
The proposal also raises questions about player welfare, as teams could potentially play up to 20 games in a single season.
While these discussions remain in the early stages, the explosive reaction from fans signals that the college football community would likely resist any move toward a 28-team playoff.
