‘Overrated’ — Lane Kiffin’s Ed Orgeron Addition Exposes LSU’s Biggest Flaw Under Brian Kelly

Following Lane Kiffin's hiring of Ed Orgeron, JD Pickell said LSU was missing the physicality under Brian Kelly that once defined the Tigers.

Lane Kiffin is bringing Ed Orgeron back to Baton Rouge to serve as a special assistant to recruiting and defense. This is a full circle moment for the Tigers, as Orgeron had a quite meaningful stint with the program once.

PFSN 2026-2027 CFB Playoff Predictor
Play out the entire college football season with PFSN's CFB Playoff Predictor to see what it means for conference standings and the CFB playoffs!

Why Did Lane Kiffin’s Ed Orgeron Hire Spark Criticism of Brian Kelly’s LSU?

According to On3’s JD Pickell, LSU completely lost its “physical” identity last season under Brian Kelly, and that identity is now expected to return with Orgeron’s arrival at Kiffin’s staff.

“LSU is one of those unique jobs where I think fit is overrated,” Pickell said. “The personality last year for LSU under Brian Kelly was unfreaking recognizable. If you don’t believe me, go back to Brian Kelly’s last game. They were emptying Tiger Stadium for a home game at night against Texas A&M in the fourth quarter. That place was barren and overrun by A&M fans. It’s not LSU’s personality.

“They were talented. They’re always going to be talented. LSU has had a bunch of draft picks since the most recent NFL draft, but it’s not about having talent and having draft picks and those things. It’s about how you play a certain style of ball? Are you physical enough at a place like LSU to win the games that you’re supposed to win? So Ed Orgeron is going to be grabbing the recruiting trail obviously, but I get more excited about the personality he brings that LSU is missing a season ago.”

Kelly was fired midway through last season during the fourth year of his tenure. Before him, Orgeron spent six seasons leading LSU and led the Tigers to an undefeated national championship run in 2019 behind Joe Burrow.

Orgeron finished his LSU coaching tenure with a 51-20 overall record before departing after the 2021 season. The program declined after the championship run, but few coaches have matched the standard set by that Burrow-led squad.

As for Orgeron’s current tenure, he reportedly signed a one-year deal to return to LSU, which runs through January 2027 and will pay him $100,000. That figure is far below the roughly $9 million he earned in his final season as head coach, as he will get paid one-fourth of that amount in monthly increments over the next 12 months. However, the man loves the Tigers, and that only matters.

Read More: ‘Absolutely Unhinged’ : CFB World Reacts As Ed Orgeron Returns to LSU Under Lane Kiffin

As an elite defensive line coach and recruiter, Orgeron is expected to play a big role on the recruiting trail as one of LSU’s approved assistant recruiters. His addition has also boosted optimism around the program, which currently has a 39.2% chance to reach the College Football Playoff in 2026, according to the PFSN CFB Playoff Meter.

More CFB Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More CFB Articles

‘Huge Mistake,’ ‘Great Move’ — CFB World Divided After ESPN Announces Major Change to College Football Broadcasts

ESPN's decision to remove the BottomLine ticker from college football broadcasts appears to have divided the fan base.

‘College Sports Are Dying Before Our Very Eyes’ — CFB World Reacts to Texas Tech Landing Thomas Castellanos After Brendan Sorsby’s Saga

CFB fans sounded off after Texas Tech landed Thomas Castellanos, adding another twist to an already chaotic quarterback offseason in Lubbock.

‘Really Poor Justification Coach,’ ‘No Shame’ — CFB Fans Rip Lane Kiffin As LSU HC Defends Welcoming Dae’Quan Wright

CFB fans rip Lane Kiffin after he defends Dae’Quan Wright’s return to college football amid a growing eligibility dispute.