Across the country, scouts are scribbling, and front offices are quietly recalibrating their boards before the 2026 NFL Draft on April 23. At the very top, things feel almost too neat with Fernando Mendoza joining the Las Vegas Raiders. But just beneath that certainty sits a far more complicated story. This is where Ty Simpson comes in, equal parts promise and question mark, depending on who you ask.
Why Ty Simpson’s NFL Draft Evaluation is Polarizing
If draft season had a personality, Simpson’s evaluation would be its most unpredictable mood swing. On paper, the case for him is easy to sketch out. He’s viewed as the No. 2 quarterback in a class that doesn’t offer many clean answers.
Jordan Reid pegs his chances as “polarizing” and that yes, he might go in the first round, but more because of supply and demand than certainty.
Because here’s the truth beneath everything: Simpson hasn’t played much. One full season as the starter for the Alabama Crimson Tide isn’t nothing, but it’s not enough to silence doubt either.
Teams picking early, like the Los Angeles Rams at No. 13 or the New York Jets at No. 16, want something sturdy, something they can point to when the decision gets questioned in November. Simpson, for all his traits, still feels like a projection.
According to Reid, quarterbacks with limited college starts don’t usually go early, and when they do, they tend to come with a warning label. For every success story like Cam Newton, there’s a riskier bet in the mold of Anthony Richardson. These are players drafted on potential, not proof, with outcomes that can swing wildly.
“I just don’t see Ty Simpson being that first round quarterback..
I would feel more comfortable taking him in the second round” ~ @Jordan_Reid #PMSLive pic.twitter.com/VZAVYKLwxI
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) March 27, 2026
That’s the uncomfortable truth at the center of Simpson’s evaluation. Drafting him in the top 16 wouldn’t just be a pick. It would be a belief that what he might become matters more than what he’s shown so far.
And that’s not a decision teams make lightly.
If Simpson’s story has a natural landing spot, it might come later, in that quieter stretch of the first round where risk feels more manageable.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
The Pittsburgh Steelers at No. 21 are also a possibility. So is a more creative scenario: the Arizona Cardinals trading back into Round 1, perhaps around pick No. 28. With veterans like Jacoby Brissett and Gardner Minshew already in place, Arizona has something many teams don’t: time.
And time might be the one thing Simpson needs most. Somewhere between urgency and restraint, his name will be called. The only question is whether it comes with conviction or crossed fingers.
