There’s something to be said for being a fixture at a blue-blood college football dynasty, but how far will that alone get you? Ohio State linebacker Tuf Borland has the experience and the pedigree, but does he offer enough individually to be a 2021 NFL Draft prospect? Let’s take a closer look.
Tuf Borland NFL Draft Profile
- Position: Linebacker
- School: Ohio State
- Current Year: Redshirt Senior
- Height: 6’0 1/8″
- Weight: 229 pounds
- Wingspan: 77″
- Arm: 31″
- Hand: 10″
Podcast: Between the Hashes Note: This article continues after the podcast player. To subscribe to Between the Hashes with Tony Pauline and Cam Mellor, find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast player.
Tony Pauline’s Tuf Borland Scouting Report
Positives: Smart, physical linebacker with poor size and speed. Plays heads-up football, shows excellent recognition and remains disciplined with assignments. Takes proper angles, possesses an outstanding first step to the action, and chases plays hard. Sells out on the blitz, breaks down well, and uses his hands to protect himself. Shows potential in zone coverage. Nicely redirects to the ball handler and wraps up tackling.
Negatives: Not very fast, lacks a burst, and cannot get out to the flanks in time. Overpursues the action on occasion.
Analysis: Borland was a very productive linebacker at the college level who comes with limited physical skills. His instincts and toughness lead me to believe he will make it as a backup linebacker/special teams player at the next level.
Tuf Borland Player Profile
Many players from the 2016 recruiting class have either graduated or moved on to the NFL at this point. Ohio State linebacker Tuf Borland, however, remains. Twilight is falling on the three-time captain’s college football career. For five years, he hasn’t had to think about what’s next. But now, that’s on the doorstep.
Borland began his career as a three-star linebacker prospect from Bolingbrook, Illinois. Right in the heart of Big Ten country, Borland received offers from Michigan State, Illinois, Iowa, Northwestern, Penn State, Purdue, and Wisconsin. But an advance from the class of the Big Ten — the Ohio State Buckeyes — proved too enticing to turn down, and Borland signed with Urban Meyer’s squad.
The Buckeyes would soon transition from the Meyer era to upstart head coach Ryan Day. Still, amidst coaching changes and injuries, Borland remained a steady constant, and he left an impression despite his obscure draft projection.
Borland’s career as an Ohio State linebacker
After playing just one game in 2016, Borland redshirted and returned as a second-year freshman in 2017. As a redshirt freshman, Borland emerged into a more impactful defensive role. In a linebacker group that included Jerome Baker and Malik Harrison, Borland managed to eclipse 50 tackles while supplementing his stat sheet with a sack.
Borland planned to return with even more vigor in 2018. However, his plans were put on halt when he tore his Achilles tendon in March during spring practices. Achilles injuries can be devastating for athletes, but Borland pushed through his rehabilitation and ended up not missing a game in 2018 while also logging a career-high 67 tackles.
Borland remained a team captain and a full-time starter in 2019, and while he’s only played five games in 2020, he’s remained a regular defensive contributor.
On the year, Borland has 26 total tackles, 3.5 tackles for loss, and 1.5 sacks. Like fellow senior Trey Sermon, Borland also accepted an invite to the Senior Bowl.
Tuf Borland struggled in National Championship loss
The Crimson Tide offense abused Ohio State’s defense in a 52-24 National Championship loss. The Buckeyes’ secondary was a large source of ire, but so too was the linebacking core. Baron Browning made a few plays, but Tuf Borland and Pete Werner were less consistent. Borland, in particular, did not move the needle. Borland was consistently sealed off at the point of attack in run defense. Additionally, in pass defense, his lack of compensatory athleticism made him a target for the meticulous Steve Sarkisian.
This mismatch was embodied best by a late-first half touchdown by DeVonta Smith. A safety rotation up top gave Smith a window behind Borland, and his speed easily surpassed the linebacker’s. All Smith had to do was run past Borland, and Borland didn’t have the recovery athleticism or closing speed to keep up. Borland was a valuable leader in his time with the Buckeyes, but his days of being in the starting lineup might be over now.
Are Tuf Borland’s traits conducive to 2021 NFL Draft interest?
Tuf Borland has an All-American name, and his game brings some intrigue as well. Borland has decent size at 6-foot-1, 234 pounds, and he’s built with density. His experience forged a bit of mental security as well. Borland brings decent awareness in coverage. Additionally, he also shows flashes recognizing gaps and anticipating where to fill in.
Borland’s speed noticeably suffered in 2018, the season after he tore his Achilles. There were reps when Borland’s speed served as a noticeable liability. To his credit, he appeared to improve that in 2019 and 2020.
While he doesn’t have great speed or range, he worked his way back to the mid-4.7, mid-4.8 range. Borland also has a modest degree of short-area burst, which can help him move along the line of scrimmage.
Featured | Pauline’s First Round 2021 NFL Mock Draft
Issues with Borland stem from his general consistency and NFL upside. While he remained a steady mental leader in his five years at Ohio State, his play on the field was not consistently at NFL quality. His relatively short wingspan limits his ability in pursuit. There are also times when his streaky angles and tackling errors hinder his ability to finish plays.
Borland has some instinct in coverage, but he doesn’t have the athletic profile to succeed consistently if he has to close ground. He doesn’t have the power to close that athleticism gap, either.
Borland was the third-best linebacker at Ohio State, behind Baron Browning and Pete Werner. His greatest appeal will come from his on-field motor, leadership ability, and perseverance through adversity. Borland likely won’t be a starter at the next level, but he projects well as a backup and special teams standout.
Tuf Borland’s best fits in the 2021 NFL Draft
Borland had a chance to show off his leadership ability at the Senior Bowl, but his lacking athleticism was what stood out the most, as he was frequently beaten in coverage. Teams need more than leadership to bank on players with early picks, and Borland doesn’t have enough athletic potential in that regard. His pro day results were candidly awful, as he logged a 4.98 40-yard dash and poor athletic marks across the board. Nevertheless, on late Day 3, Borland brings some limited value as a backup who can contribute on special teams.
There aren’t necessarily specific team fits for Borland. It’s unlikely that he’ll receive consistent playing time on the defensive side of the ball. Borland can serve as depth and special teams reinforcement for teams with both 4-3 and 3-4 alignments.
At this point, it’s not even a given that Borland will be drafted, and as more linebackers ascend, Borland’s odds dwindle. He simply doesn’t have the athletic traits necessary to succeed, and as experienced as he is, his experience doesn’t begin to close the gap that his poor athletic traits have created. With his motor and work ethic, the Ohio State linebacker could earn a special teams role as a late-round pick or undrafted free agent. However, that will likely be his ceiling.
Want more 2021 NFL Draft prospect news? Want to do your own mock draft?
Dive into PFN’s Free NFL Mock Draft Simulator and test your own drafting acumen. Continue to visit Pro Football Network for NFL news and in-depth analysis. Also, be sure to follow us on Twitter (@PFN365) to stay in the loop on all things college football and the NFL Draft landscape.