The Edmonton Oilers find themselves at the center of another major conversation as their search for a new head coach has led them to a potentially unexpected hire.
Mike Babcock’s name has rapidly become one of the most talked-about storylines surrounding the franchise, bringing equal parts intrigue and controversy. His track record speaks for itself, but so do the questions that have followed him in recent years.
As Edmonton weighs its options, one respected Oilers voice has stepped forward with a strong endorsement that could turn heads across the hockey world.
Craig MacTavish Makes Strong Case for Mike Babcock as Oilers Head Coach
Babcock has emerged as one of the leading candidates for Edmonton’s coaching vacancy, and former Oilers head coach and executive Craig MacTavish believes the organization could strike gold if it ultimately makes the hire.
Speaking with Bob Stauffer on Oilers Now, MacTavish shared an honest assessment of Babcock, acknowledging both the accomplishments and the baggage that come with his name.
While many around the league continue to debate whether Babcock deserves another NHL opportunity, MacTavish made it clear that he sees far more upside than risk.
“Mike Babcock, it could be an absolute home run for the Edmonton Oilers,” MacTavish said. “He’s got a lot of great qualities. I always thought that he was super sharp.”
At the same time, he admitted that Babcock developed a reputation for being demanding, occasionally condescending, and extremely tough on players throughout different stages of his career.
“I think the negative connotations about Mike, as I coached against him, were that he always kind of had to be the smartest guy in their dressing room,” MacTavish continued.
“And most times he was. There weren’t a lot of guys who knew more about hockey than Babcock. And I think he didn’t suffer fools very well. And I think condescending comments to his players and being overly critical of the players were some of the things that I was hearing back in the day.”
Still, MacTavish believes growth and accountability matter. “People evolve. I mean, give the guy a chance,” he said during the discussion, arguing that coaches should not be permanently defined by earlier chapters of their careers. He pointed to John Tortorella as an example of a coach whose public image has changed significantly over time.
The former Oilers bench boss revisited the topic during another segment of the show and doubled down on his position. Asked directly whether Babcock deserved another opportunity in the NHL, MacTavish offered a straightforward answer.
“Yeah, I think second chance, I’m all for that. We all learn from our mistakes,” MacTavish said. “I’m sure Mike is in that category.” He later added that despite their competitive history, he still believes hiring Babcock “could be a home run for the Oilers.”
A major part of MacTavish’s argument centers on leadership. In his view, Edmonton needs a coach with enough presence to challenge everyone in the room, including its biggest stars. He suggested that difficult conversations are sometimes necessary on championship-caliber teams and believes Babcock has never been afraid of those moments.
MacTavish also pointed to Zach Hyman’s experience of playing under Babcock in Toronto. He noted that Hyman’s voice carries significant influence within Edmonton’s locker room and hinted that the veteran forward’s opinion would hold considerable weight during any discussions about the potential hire.
Meanwhile, the Oilers continue conducting extensive background checks before making a final decision. Reports indicate the team has consulted the NHLPA, spoken with ownership, and engaged members of the team’s leadership group as part of a thorough review process.
This caution is understandable given Babcock’s history. His 2023 exit from Columbus following an NHLPA investigation, along with previous allegations involving player treatment in Toronto and Detroit, remain central parts of the conversation surrounding his candidacy.
Yet his coaching resume remains among the strongest in modern hockey. Babcock owns 700 career NHL wins, captured a Stanley Cup with Detroit in 2008, and won two Olympic gold medals with Team Canada.
ALSO READ: Oilers Insider Puts EDM on Blast Over Mike Babcock Links
As the Oilers continue sorting through one of the most consequential decisions facing the organization, MacTavish has left little doubt about where he stands: he believes Babcock deserves a legitimate shot at leading Edmonton.
