The Vegas Golden Knights looked poised to seize control of the Stanley Cup Final, but Game 5 felt like a missed opportunity that may end up defining their season.
Costly special teams breakdowns, the loss of a key forward, and an unusually quiet night from some of Vegas’ biggest stars allowed Carolina to grab the momentum when it mattered most.
Now trailing 3-2 in the series, the pressure has shifted squarely onto the Golden Knights as they head home facing elimination. In the aftermath, much of the attention has centered on one of Vegas’ postseason leaders, Mitch Marner, after a performance that left many wanting more on hockey’s biggest stage.
Jay Rosehill Revives Old Mitch Marner Criticism After Silent Game 5 Performance
Former Maple Leafs enforcer Jay Rosehill did not hold back after Marner was unable to make an impact in the Golden Knights’ 4-2 loss to the Carolina Hurricanes in Game 5 of the Stanley Cup Final.
Marner finished the night without a point, recorded a minus-1 rating, and managed a solitary shot on goal as Carolina grabbed control of the series. The missing effort stood out because the Vegas winger had been one of the NHL’s most dangerous offensive players throughout the postseason and entered the game riding a 4-game point streak.
Following the loss, Rosehill took to X and delivered a pointed jab aimed directly at Marner’s long-discussed playoff reputation.
“Anyone notice Marner tonight? Was it a Game 5-7 or something?” Rosehill wrote, mocking the former Toronto forward.
The remark was not simply about one game. It referenced a criticism that followed Marner during his years with the Toronto Maple Leafs, where opponents and critics frequently questioned his effectiveness in the later stages of playoff series.
Game 5 provided ammunition for those arguments. Vegas opened the scoring on a Pavel Dorofeyev power-play goal, but Carolina quickly responded and took control with three unanswered goals before the third period. The Hurricanes’ special teams proved decisive, converting twice on the power play while limiting Vegas’ offensive opportunities.
Marner struggled to generate quality chances against Carolina’s defensive structure, and the situation became even more challenging when William Karlsson exited with an arm injury during the second period. Karlsson’s departure disrupted one of Vegas’ key forward combinations and removed an important support piece from the lineup.
Despite the criticism, Marner’s overall postseason body of work remains difficult to ignore. Through 21 playoff games, he has produced 29 points, including ten goals and 19 assists, a mark leading all NHL players. His 19 assists rank first among playoff skaters, and his 29 points put him well ahead of the field entering Game 6.
He has also delivered several signature moments during Vegas’ run to the Final. Most notably, Marner recorded the fastest hat trick in Stanley Cup Final history during Game 3 against Carolina, scoring three goals in just six minutes and ten seconds. He also established a new Golden Knights franchise record for points in a single postseason.
That production is why Rosehill’s comment generated attention. The criticism was directed at a player who has largely rewritten his playoff narrative since arriving in Vegas after his 2025 trade from Toronto.
Throughout this postseason, Marner has been a driving force behind the Golden Knights’ success and has frequently been mentioned as a leading Conn Smythe Trophy candidate.
ALSO READ: Bruce Cassidy’s Stance Towards Maple Leafs’ Head Coach Job Draws Strong Reaction From NHL Fans
Still, with the Golden Knights now one loss away from seeing their championship hopes disappear, individual accomplishments will matter far less than the result on the scoreboard.
Game 6 presents Marner with an opportunity to answer the criticism directly and help extend Vegas’ season before the Hurricanes can finish the job.
