The Edmonton Oilers continue to collect wins as they push for the Pacific Division crown, but the conversation around the team is full of doubt. Even after a solid result against San Jose, attention has moved away from the score and toward the crease, where decisions involving Tristan Jarry and Connor Ingram raised fresh concerns.
The offense has been the Oilers’ strength, yet questions about the team’s direction in goal remain. This situation has resurfaced the debate about whether Edmonton is still overlooking its most important position.
Why Tyson Nash Questions the Oilers’ Handling of Connor Ingram and Tristan Jarry
Ingram’s early exit during Wednesday’s win over San Jose was concerning, even though the team described it as precautionary. He left after two periods due to discomfort, and while he stayed on the bench and even stretched during the third, the decision raises genuine questions about how secure the Oilers are with their goaltending setup.
Jarry stepped in and stopped all four shots he faced, but things can go wrong if the Oilers’ starting choice has to be sidelined in crucial upcoming games.
That concern was discussed before the game by former NHL forward Tyson Nash, who did not hold back while discussing Edmonton’s bigger picture in net. Speaking on “TSN OverDrive,” Nash questioned how a team with elite talent has not addressed its goaltending more decisively.
“How the Edmonton Oilers haven’t gone out and got a number one goaltender is absolutely mind-boggling to me,” he said, pointing directly at what he sees as a long-standing issue. He then mentioned, “You got the two best players in the world, and you don’t have a number one goaltender.”
Nash also highlighted the uncertainty that has followed the Oilers through recent seasons, including last year’s playoff run. “They don’t know who their starter is. That’s a problem,” he said about Game 6 of the 2025 Stanley Cup Final, comparing the situation to teams like the Florida Panthers and Tampa Bay Lightning with clear No. 1 options.
He noted that championship teams rely on stability in goal, pointing out that dominant starters often make the backup almost irrelevant in big moments. He said the Panthers and Lightning “had the best number one on the planet, and that’s how you win Stanley Cups.”
The Oilers have tried to reshape that position during the 2025-26 season. A mid-season trade brought Jarry into the mix, while earlier struggles from Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard forced changes.
That made the situation more uncomfortable, but Ingram provided some stability during their playoff push, emerging as the leading option. Still, his numbers are inconsistent compared to those of the top teams’ starters.
Through 79 games, Edmonton’s goaltenders combined for a .877 save percentage, placing them near the bottom of the league. That stat reflects the broader issue Nash pointed to, where talent up front has not been matched by reliability in net.
Nash also expanded his criticism beyond goaltending, arguing that the team lacks depth in key areas. “I just think they’re lacking the foot soldiers,” he said, stressing that supporting players often decide playoff outcomes. He compared Edmonton’s current roster to past championship teams that relied on strong depth beyond star players, saying, “I just think they lack big time in that area.”
Despite those concerns, the Oilers remain in first place in the Pacific Division with 90 points. Their offense, led by Connor McDavid, continues to pull results, and their power play ranks first in the league. However, defensive lapses and concerns in net have prevented them from reaching the level of previous seasons.
ALSO READ: Oilers HC Addresses Why Connor Ingram Was Pulled From SJ Sharks Game
