The Cleveland Browns gave Shedeur Sanders the first half against the Buffalo Bills on Saturday. One interception quickly became a debate over whether the quarterback deserved all the blame.
Sanders’ red zone pass intended for Jermaine Terry wound up in the hands of Bills safety Damar Hamlin. Robert Griffin III defended Sanders after the play, but several fans pushed back on the former Pro Bowl quarterback.
NFL Fans Push Back on Robert Griffin III’s Shedeur Sanders Defense
Griffin defended Sanders by saying, “Drops should not count on a QB’s stat line. Drops that turn into ints shouldn’t count on a QB’s stat line.”
Adam Pratt went directly to challenge Griffin’s assessment. “That wasn’t a drop RG3; it was a bad pass. Come on, be fair, bro,” he wrote in an X post.
That wasnt a drop RG3 it was a bad pass. Come on be fair bro
— Adam Pratt (@TheAdamPratt) August 22, 2026
Another fan argued that Sanders’ placement was part of the problem. “Shedeur threw it behind him, it’s just as much his fault as the receivers,” the fan wrote in a separate reply.
BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM: PFN’s Free NFL Mock Draft Simulator
Tyler Ziskin took issue with the larger idea of separating quarterback statistics from mistakes made by teammates. “This is a stupid (expletive) take. We taking the incredible WR plays that shouldn’t be catches off the board too? It’s a team game,” he wrote in his post.
Garrett Kelly followed the same logic, noting that quarterbacks also benefit when receivers rescue inaccurate throws.
“Amazing catches on poorly thrown balls shouldn’t count as completions, TD’s, or yards for the QB. Lost yards on missed blocks shouldn’t count against RB’s,” he wrote in his reply. “And the list goes on if we all want to play that game. It all washes out in the end.”
Amazing catches on poorly thrown balls shouldn’t count as completions, TD’s, or yards for the QB.
Lost yards on missed blocks shouldn’t count against RB’s
And the list goes on if we all want to play that game. It all washes out in the end.
— Garrett Kelly (@gkelly17) August 22, 2026
BankHead was equally opposed to changing how the play should be scored. “Nah, don’t start messing with stats and records now. Unless you retroactively go back and correct every QB’s stats,” the fan wrote in another reply.
Nah don’t start messing with stats and records now. Unless you retroactively go back and correct every QB’s stats
— BankHead (@Tippinbets) August 22, 2026
The pushback centered on a simple point. Terry had a chance to make the catch, but Sanders did not put the ball in an ideal spot. Fans were not willing to treat those two things as mutually exclusive.
START PREPARING: PFN’s Free Fantasy Draft Simulator
Shedeur Sanders’ Bills Start Adds to Browns QB Debate
In the game against the Bills, Sanders threw for 74 passing yards, 1 touchdown, and 1 interception in the first half of a 31-7 loss. He led the Browns’ only touchdown drive, finishing it with an 8-yard scoring pass to Luke Floriea.
Sanders entered this preseason trying to improve on an uneven rookie season. He finished 2025 with a 63.0 QB Impact score, ranking 37th among 38 qualifying quarterbacks. He threw for 1,400 yards, 7 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions last season.
Griffin has been one of Sanders’ most vocal supporters this summer, previously calling for Cleveland to name him the starting quarterback. Saturday gave him another chance to defend the young quarterback.
Fans were not interested in giving Sanders a statistical mulligan. Their argument was straightforward: the receiver could have caught it, and the quarterback still could have thrown it better.
