The Naismith Player of the Year Award stands as one of the most respected honors in college basketball, recognizing the top men’s and women’s performers each season. Named after the sport’s inventor, Dr. James Naismith, the award reflects excellence across performance, leadership, and team impact.
But beyond the headline winners, the process behind selecting the recipient is equally significant. A structured system involving expert voters, staged evaluations, and limited fan input ensures the decision carries both credibility and broad engagement.
How the Naismith Player of the Year Selection Process Works
The path to winning the Naismith Trophy begins long before the final announcement. Each season opens with a preseason watch list featuring 50 players, compiled by the Atlanta Tipoff Club’s Board of Selectors.
That group is gradually reduced as the season unfolds, first to 30 midseason candidates, then to 10 semifinalists, and eventually to four finalists in late March. The 2026 cycle has followed this same structure, with semifinalists recently announced.
At every stage, players are judged on a combination of individual output and broader influence. Evaluators look closely at statistical production, leadership qualities, and how a player contributes to team success during both the regular season and conference tournaments.
Unlike some other major awards, the Naismith winner is revealed in April before the NCAA Tournament concludes. That timing places added emphasis on the full body of work across the season rather than postseason results alone. The system has consistently produced elite winners, including 2025 recipient Cooper Flagg of Duke, who edged out other finalists, including Purdue’s Braden Smith.
MARCH MADNESS: Fill In Your Bracket Now!
Who Votes for the Naismith Trophy?
The final decision rests primarily with a national voting academy made up of coaches, administrators, and journalists from across the United States. This group conducts ballots to ultimately determine the four-player final ballot and select the winner.
Fan participation adds a secondary layer to the outcome. Through official platforms such as naismithfanvote.com, supporters can cast one vote per day. While this introduces a public element, its influence remains limited, accounting for 5% of the total vote.
The award’s structure has remained largely unchanged as of March 2026, maintaining a balance between expert evaluation and fan engagement. This hybrid approach helps preserve the integrity of the honor while still allowing broader participation.
First awarded in 1969 to UCLA’s Lew Alcindor (later known as Kareem Abdul-Jabbar), the Naismith Trophy has expanded over time. The women’s award was introduced in 1983, with Anne Donovan as its inaugural winner. Additional categories now include honors for defensive players, high school athletes, and coaches, reflecting the award’s wider role in celebrating basketball excellence.
