The death of Buffalo Bills defensive tackle Ed Oliver’s two-year-old son has sparked a sharp debate around privacy, empathy, and standards in sports journalism. Details surrounding the tragedy remained private for nearly two months before surfacing publicly, drawing scrutiny over how independent sources share sensitive issues.
This reporting has now drawn a strong response from veteran sports writer and author Jeff Pearlman.
Jeff Pearlman Calls Out Tony Farmer’s Ed Oliver Reporting
Pearlman criticized independent journalist Tony Farmer for publishing details surrounding Oliver’s son’s death and including images that showed the Bills’ defensive player grieving at his Texas home. The child died June 28 after an accidental drowning at the family’s residence in Huffman, Texas, near Houston.
Oliver and his partner, Dymond Gladney, had kept the tragedy private and requested privacy and prayers. The Bills also declined to publicly discuss the situation until the news began circulating in August, when the organization confirmed the death and offered its support to Oliver’s family.
Farmer defended his reporting by claiming there had been a “media blackout” around the death. He argued that the Bills’ reporters knew about the situation but had chosen not to publish it, while also saying homicide detectives were involved in the case.
BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM: PFN’s Free NFL Mock Draft Simulator
Pearlman, however, focused less on whether the information could be obtained and more on whether it should have been published.
“There are lines in journalism that you don’t cross,” Pearlman said. “There are just certain things you respect.”
Jeff Pearlman really explains this whole Ed Oliver horrible situation so well. Shame on that farmer guy #billsmafia pic.twitter.com/IBdJHud8Uj
— Carli Zielinski (@carlifarley) August 23, 2026
The use of images became another major concern for Pearlman. Farmer’s report included footage showing Oliver visibly distraught while speaking with police officers following the tragedy.
Pearlman argued that such images could remain attached to Oliver indefinitely because anything published online continues to circulate even after the original story disappears.
“This guy, Tony Farmer, … officially broke it, that Ed Oliver isn’t missing practice because of injury; he’s missing practice because he recovered from the death of a child but runs these pictures of Ed Oliver in the lowest moment of his life,” Pearlman said. “And pictures, once they’re seen, they don’t go away. All right, once they’re seen, they don’t go away.”
START PREPARING: PFN’s Free Fantasy Draft Simulator
He also rejected the notion that nearly two months was sufficient time to disclose the news.
“There’s no such thing when you lose a child,” Pearlman said.
He described Farmer’s approach as a “lack of professionalism” while stressing that the bigger issue was empathy and judgment.
“It’s a lack of professionalism, but more than anything, a lack of empathy,” Pearlman added. “I think it’s really, really poor judgment”
Pearlman concluded his comments by urging reporters to weigh the human emotions of their coverage, especially when covering an intensely personal loss that does not directly involve what happens on the football field.
