Jaxon Smith-Njigba led the NFL with 1,793 receiving yards in 2025. Whether he leads it again in 2026 depends less on his own ceiling and more on who else is healthy.
That tension framed the latest Football Debate Club, where PFSN’s Ian Cummings and NFL analyst Josh Hite split on whether Smith-Njigba can repeat as receiving yards leader. Hite said yes. Cummings said not necessarily. Host Cam Mellor sided with Cummings, 3-2.
The Case Against Repeating as NFL Receiving Yards Leader
Cummings flagged two specific receivers as more efficient candidates than Smith-Njigba.
“Last year he had an elite 94.4 PFSN WR Impact grade and a 34 percent on-field target percentage,” Cummings said. “But there was one receiver in the NFL who was even higher in both metrics. Puka Nacua from the Rams. And Puka Nacua has less target competition. Davante Adams is going to be 34 in December.”
The Nacua case holds up on the public data. He led the NFL in receptions in 2025 with 129 catches and finished second in receiving yards at 1,715 across 16 games. He played one fewer game than Smith-Njigba and finished 78 yards behind. The Rams already pushed Nacua to one of the league’s highest per-route target rates last season.
The age question on Adams matters because the Rams’ second receiver turning 34 next December means Nacua’s per-game volume in 2026 should trend up. If Adams slows in his age-34 season, the gap between Nacua and the field widens.
Then there is the Cincinnati factor.
“If you look at the Bengals, Ja’Marr Chase, he doesn’t have a wide receiver three in that offense still,” Cummings said. “And if Joe Burrow stays fully healthy, I could see him reclaiming the title that he had in 2024.”
Chase led the NFL in receiving in 2024 with 1,708 yards and won the receiving triple crown, joining Jerry Rice, Sterling Sharpe, Steve Smith and Cooper Kupp as the only receivers to lead the league in receptions, yards and touchdowns since the merger. He’s a Burrow-availability scenario away from 1,800-plus yards again.
What Could Push Smith-Njigba to Repeat
Hite’s argument leaned on a single counterintuitive number: Smith-Njigba won the title despite playing in one of the run-heaviest offenses in football.
“Last year, the Seahawks had the third most rushing attempts, tied with Baltimore with 507 attempts,” Hite said. “And he led the league in receiving yards. He could definitely do that.”
That number verifies. The Buffalo Bills (547) and New York Giants (511) led the NFL in rushing attempts in 2025. Seattle and Baltimore tied for third at 507. Seattle ran the ball as much as anyone in football and still produced an Offensive Player of the Year at receiver.
Hite added a wrinkle: he hopes Smith-Njigba doesn’t lead the league again.
“I’m hoping that due to another year within this West Coast scheme and players coming back healthy like [Tory] Horton and [Cooper] Kupp, with maybe getting [Jadarian] Price more involved in the passing game than he was at Notre Dame, we’re able to spread the love around,” Hite said. “[AJ] Barner more involved, [Elijah] Arroyo. He definitely could. He could.”
MORE FOOTBALL DEBATE CLUB:Â Why Malik Willis at $67.5 Million Was the Smart Move for the Miami Dolphins
That’s the bull case in shorthand. If Brian Fleury keeps the same scheme that produced Smith-Njigba’s NFL-leading 36.2 percent target share, the volume holds. If the offense diversifies through a returning Horton, Kupp and Arroyo, Smith-Njigba’s total dips while the team’s ceiling rises. Either outcome works for Seattle. Only one wins the receiving title.
Smith-Njigba’s path back to the top of the leaderboard runs through Puka Nacua’s health and Ja’Marr Chase’s. Both are healthy until they’re not. The same applies to Smith-Njigba. The defense of the title is harder than the original capture.
