Russell Wilson’s impressive performance against Dallas has fantasy football managers suddenly interested in a quarterback who was barely on their radar before this week. The veteran signal-caller delivered a vintage display that reminded everyone why he was once a consistent fantasy starter.
However, this breakout came against a Cowboys defense that has struggled early this season. Given his inconsistent recent track record, fantasy football owners should view Wilson as a streaming option rather than a reliable weekly starter.
Should Russell Wilson Be a Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Add in Week 3?
Rostered: 5%
Wilson delivered his best performance since his 452-yard outing against Houston in 2017, completing 30 of 41 passes for 450 yards and three touchdowns in the New York Giants’ overtime loss to Dallas. The veteran quarterback’s 450 yards were the second-most of his career and marked just the fourth time he’s eclipsed 400 yards in a single game.
Another poor performance from Wilson might have gotten him benched for rookie Jaxson Dart. Instead, he silenced critics with vintage deep-ball accuracy and pocket presence throughout the contest.
RUSSELL WILSON MOON BALL TO MALIK NABERS.
GIANTS LEAD. pic.twitter.com/Chl9HdjldL
— NFL (@NFL) September 14, 2025
Wilson didn’t turn the ball over until his abysmal game-winning interception in overtime, when he threw an ill-advised deep pass under pressure that was picked off at the Dallas 30-yard line.
Before that costly mistake, it was a masterful performance that showcased the arm talent that made him a perennial Pro Bowl selection in Seattle. His 31.3 fantasy points represent precisely the type of ceiling performance that keeps him relevant as a streaming option.
That said, Wilson is not going to face the Dallas Cowboys’ porous secondary every week, and the Giants won’t consistently be in shootouts throughout the season. This performance came against a Cowboys defense that allowed multiple explosive plays and failed to generate consistent pressure.
Wilson’s name deservedly appears on waiver wire lists because his fantasy output mandates attention, but he remains nothing more than a matchup-dependent streamer. His poor Week 1 showing against Washington’s defense demonstrates the volatility that comes with rostering the aging quarterback.
Aggressiveness Rating: 0.0
Wilson’s Fantasy Football Value: Streaming Option Despite Explosive Performance
Wilson proved he can still deliver elite fantasy production when conditions align perfectly, but this explosive performance against Dallas shouldn’t fool managers into expecting weekly consistency.
The aging quarterback remains a volatile streaming option whose success hinges heavily on favorable matchups and defensive breakdowns. While Wilson’s 450-yard showcase warrants waiver consideration, his track record suggests treating him as a situational play rather than a reliable starter. Competent managers will add Wilson for specific weeks but avoid the temptation of viewing him as a long-term solution
