Thursday Night Football Fantasy Start/Sit: Matthew Stafford, Davante Adams, Jaxon Smith-Njigba Top Options Tonight

Dominate Week 16 with expert Rams-Seahawks fantasy analysis. Who should you start and sit in this exciting Thursday night matchup?

The fantasy football landscape shifts dramatically after Week 16, as unexpected performances and emerging storylines reshape our expectations for the season ahead. Some players exceed all projections, while others leave managers scratching their heads, wondering if early concerns were justified or merely a case of growing pains.

Thursday night’s Los Angeles Rams-Seattle Seahawks matchup could provide crucial clarity on several key start/sit situations for both NFC powerhouses. Get ready to dive deep into the developments that could make or break your fantasy team’s Week 16 performance.

PFSN Dynasty Trade Calculator
Not sure if you're winning that trade? Use PFSN's FREE Dynasty Trade Calculator to find out!

Los Angeles Rams

Matthew Stafford, QB

Sportsbooks are labeling Matthew Stafford as a heavy favorite to walk away from this season with the MVP trophy, and that’s great, but I’m benching him in the semifinals of my playoffs if at all possible.

Having access to Puka Nacua means a big week is never far away, but we saw this Seattle defense get under Stafford’s skin back in Week 11 (19 yards on his 11 pressured passes), and with Davante Adams (hamstring) likely sidelined, I’m not sold on the reward outweighing the risk.

This is now a two-headed backfield that showcased their upside last week against the Lions (Kyren Williams and Blake Corum turned 26 carries into 149 yards and three scores), and given the pack of the Seahawks, are we positive that Stafford throws the ball 35 times?

32 times?

Without the rushing ability to add cheap points to his profile and (likely) Adams to transform RB dives into WR fades, Stafford scoring under 17 fantasy points for the seventh time is something I view as more likely than not to happen.

I wouldn’t play Trevor Lawrence over him in a brutal matchup, but C.J. Stroud against the Raiders? I would.

Blake Corum, RB

Remember when Tony Pollard was the lightning to Ezekiel Elliott’s thunder?

This isn’t that, but the efficiency of Corum over the past three weeks is nothing short of intoxicating.

  • 30 carries (100% gain rate)
  • 280 yards
  • 4 touchdowns

Two of those scores have come from the doorstep, one from 11 yards, and the other from 48. He has a 24+ yard run in all three of those contests and kind of looks like a player who ran for over 2,700 yards and scored 47 touchdowns over his final two collegiate seasons.

Until the Rams make this a hot hand situation and not a series-by-series one, I’m not going to be able to rank the secondary option as a flex-worthy play. His eight carries against these Seahawks in Week 11 gained just 10 yards, and that is the sort of floor that I fear in these tough matchups.

With Adams likely out, you could argue that there is more of a role to chase in scoring situations, but I’d push back and say that without the WR2, I’m not projecting as many scoring chances.

That means you’re getting a bigger piece of a smaller piece, and that essentially leaves you right where you started.

Even with all of the success, Corum’s next game with more than 13 touches will be his first this season, and he’s basically a zero in the passing game (if we are getting technical from a yardage standpoint, he’s actually been less than a zero since the beginning of November with -2 receiving yards).

He sits outside of my top 30 this week. He’s in the David Montgomery and Rhamondre Stevenson tier. There’s nothing wrong with that in a deeper format, but my guess is that in standard-sized leagues, you have a minimum of two running backs and three receivers that I’d rather play.

Kyren Williams, RB

It was a Williams game in Week 11 when these teams first met (12-91-1 on the ground while Corum ran eight times for 10 yards), and with him coming off of his third multi-TD effort of the season, he projects as the lead back, even if it’s not in a bellcow capacity.

My concern for him is the passing game. He had eight catches against the Niners back in Week 5, but he hasn’t caught more than two balls in a game since. That creates an uncomfortable floor situation should a short TD not go his way or Corum score from distance.

That said, with TD vulture Adams sidelined, Williams’ role in close is more valuable this week than most, and that positions him to be a top 15 RB to kick off this week.

Davante Adams, WR

Adams entered Week 15 with a hamstring injury and exited the week with it getting worse.

All signs point to him missing this game on short rest and, based on the first meeting (a one-yard TD being his only reception on eight targets), maybe that’s a blessing in disguise for fantasy managers in the semifinals.

Before the injury, he earned nine targets against the Lions, his most since Week 5, and while he only hauled in four (71 yards), that level of involvement would have me singing an optimistic tune given the value of where those targets come from for the veteran.

There isn’t a receiver that has my eye in Los Angeles. Still, this injury does open the door for Colby “the scoring machine” Parkinson to continue his surge as a viable streaming option at the position, something I never saw coming.

Puka Nacua, WR

Nacua is a warrior, and that’s all there is to it.

He’s relatable. Not in talent, I have no idea what it’s like to be among the best in the world at something, but he loves the sport and just wants to play. He seems to love the competition, the contact, and everything in between. He’s about as easy a player to root for as there is in the league, and if you haven’t gone out of your way to watch a Rams game, I hope you enjoy this island game.

Nacua had a weird, bad drop in the first quarter last week, but it made no difference. This offense funnels everything they want to do through him, and the early mistake may have encouraged Stafford to feature his top threat at an even higher degree to ensure he remained engaged.

MORE: Free Fantasy Start/Sit Lineup Optimizer

He caught nine of his other 10 targets for 181 yards, his second straight game with over 160 yards and third such performance of the season. Los Angeles even handed him the ball twice (zero carries in the three games prior), and I suspect we see more of that as the value of these games spikes.

For Week 16, even in a brutal matchup, Nacua sits atop my wide receiver rankings. Adams is likely to miss this game, and that only ramps up the volume further. In the Week 11 meeting against these stingy Seahawks, he had seven catches for 75 yards while all of his teammates combined had eight for 55.

He was also handed the ball twice in that contest. Sean McVay, Stafford, and you all want the same thing: it’s beautiful when things align like that, and that makes Nacua as inevitable as any receiver in the game today.

Colby Parkinson, TE

Is it possible that Rob Gronkowski walked so Colby Parkinson could run?

The Stanford product has scored in five of his past six games, a run that nearly had an asterisk on it after his first TD was highly questionable against the Lions, but he squashed those concerns with a second score later.

2016-25, Highest TD% By A TE (min.35 targets)

  1. 2020 Robert Tonyan: 18.6%
  2. 2024 Mark Andrews: 15.9%
  3. 2025 Parkinson: 15.8%
  4. 2017 OJ Howard: 15.4%
  5. 2016 Hunter Henry: 14.9%

It should go without saying that regression is to be expected, but regression can be a long-term thing, and we are very much in the short-term portion of the season.

Parkinson has earned an end zone look in four straight games (three more than he had for the season prior), and all signs point to Adams (hamstring) being highly limited if not out altogether this week.

With an MVP candidate under center and the leader in end zone targets compromised at best, the situation around this unsustainable production is as advantageous as it’s been.

I was encouraged by the 9.0-yard aDOT on Sunday, a sign that Sean McVay is interested in exploring exactly what his emerging tight end can do vertically. This position has become harder, not easier, with time to rank (injuries to Daniel Jones and Patrick Mahomes, timeshares in Buffalo and Baltimore, etc.), and that has paved the way for Parkinson to enter my top 10 for the first time this season.

Seattle Seahawks

Sam Darnold, QB

The Seahawks continue to win, and it requires very little from their starting quarterback.

Sam Darnold failed to throw a touchdown pass on Sunday, his third such outing over his past five games, one of which was the first game against these Rams (29-of-44 for 279 yards and four interceptions).

I don’t think we are in danger of a repeat performance, if for no other reason than airballs like that don’t happen often to playoff teams. However, they had a simple game plan and executed it at a high level.

In that Los Angeles win, Darnold had 13 pressured passes, and they netted just 40 yards and three turnovers. I expect this offense to be prepared for that sort of aggression this week. With Rashid Shaheed more comfortable in his role, I do think there’s some upside to a contrarian Darnold angle, be it for betting or DFS showdown situations.

Even with that take, I can’t get Darnold inside of my top 15 at the position: He’s not someone to trust with your season on the line, but that’s been the case for the past two months. There are streaming options that offer more upside with less risk.

Kenneth Walker III, RB

At this point, you know the team: explosive talent with limited touch upside and minimal scoring equity.

The Seahawks gave him their first five carries on Sunday against the Colts, begging him to establish himself as the leader of this backfield, and he rewarded them with … six yards.

It was a split with Zach Charbonnet from then on out, and that meant a lot of nothing for fantasy managers. Walker has been held under a dozen carries in three of his past four games and has scored just one TD since September.

It should be noted that he totaled 111 yards and a touchdown in the first meeting with these Rams. He picked up yardage on all 16 of his carries, and I think that’s probably enough to earn him an extended first-quarter look again, but that assures us of nothing.

I have Walker ranked as RB25 this week, fully knowing that if he hits, I’m way too low, and if not, I’m 20 spots too high.

Zach Charbonnet, RB

It would appear that the Seahawks are begging Kenneth Walker to take control of this backfield by giving him almost all of the early work, but he’s been unable to capitalize.

That isn’t good for everyone.

Snap Rates, Week 15 vs. Colts

  • Kenneth Walker: 87.5% in Q1, 35.3% after that
  • Charbonnet: 12.5% in Q1, 60.8% after that

Charbonnet is averaging 3.7 yards per carry with 14 targets for the season. His role/skill set isn’t meant to be fantasy relevant if he’s not scoring touchdowns, and as his involvement in the early scripted plays declines, those scoring opportunities, even in a good offense, stand to be few and far between.

MORE: Free Fantasy Waiver Wire Tool

On Sunday against the Colts, he ran eight times for 31 yards, nearly identical to the 11 for 37 line he put up in the first meeting with these Rams.

He has the red zone role (eight rushing scores this season) and is the clear “well, if Walker isn’t going to do anything productive, let’s pivot” option, but that’s pretty tough to bank on pregame, as the touch projection isn’t going to clear 10 with any level of confidence.

When these teams first met, it was a race to 20 points, and in that sort of game atmosphere, there’s even less upside for a player like Charbonnet than normal.

Cooper Kupp, WR

Cooper Kupp caught five of seven targets on Sunday against the Colts in a surprisingly competitive game. It was his third game with at least a handful of receptions this season and his first since Week 5.

It’s noise.

I’m not counting on this level of involvement in a short week. The Seahawks couldn’t run the ball over the weekend (22 carries for 50 yards), and that led to more volume through the air than usual. Kupp accounted for just under 17% of Seattle’s receiving yards, and if that rate sustains, he’s not going to be close to viable most weeks.

Shaheed is looking slightly more comfortable in this offense with each passing week, and AJ Barner saw another six targets over the weekend. What we got in Week 15 was on the high end of expectations, and is 9.6 PPR points really the type of ceiling you want to be chasing?

Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR

Jaxon Smith-Njigba has cleared 18 PPR points in 12 of 14 games this season and is proving more than capable of winning at every level.

Against the Colts last week, JSN posted his ninth 100-yard effort of the season and did so on his second-lowest aDOT of the season (7.7 yards) courtesy of his second-highest slot participation rate.

That’s more detail than you realistically care about, but it speaks to Seattle’s desire to find ways to feed their WR1 at a high level as opposed to working to get other pass catchers involved.

In the Week 11 matchup against the Rams, Smith-Njigba turned 12 targets into nine catches for 105 yards. Status quo. If you’re searching for the JSN nugget of the week, he’s caught nine of 10 targets from the slot over the past month, a role he didn’t have against the Rams in the first meeting (zero targets on six routes).

Rashid Shaheed, WR

If you’re considering Shaheed on Thursday night in this tough matchup, you know what you’re signing up for.

There isn’t a floor to chase, and the skill set comes with a ton of risk when attached to the slow stylings of this offense.

That said, I think you could do worse if you’re managing a plucky underdog and taking on the best team in your league.

Shaheed has seen his target share rise in three straight weeks, and his 106 air yards last week were his most since joining the ‘Hawks in Week 10. His statistically strong Week 15 also saw him earn his first end zone target in a month, and with the Rams likely to bring jailbreak pressure schemes, the odds of this significant play threat getting loose for a single impact catch are as high, in my opinion, as they’ve been since the trade.

The low volume keeps him ranked outside of my top 30, but that’s a ranking based on a median projection. If you’re in a spot where you can swallow risk for reward, I think this is a sharp way to do it.

AJ Barner, TE

I assume you’re reading this section because you want to recreate the magic from the Week 11 meeting: 10 catches on 11 targets for 70 yards.

That performance looked good in the moment, as Barner was able to succeed next to, not at the expense of, Smith-Njigba (28.6% target share with north of 100 yards), but it’s looked like fool’s gold ever since.

MORE: Fantasy Football Trade Analyzer

In the four games prior, he has totaled 12 catches and 107 yards. I know we had the weird 61-yard catch back in Week 6 against the Jags, but Barner doesn’t have a reception gaining more than 15 yards in a game since, and that means you’re relying on volume in an offense that ranks 26th in plays per game this season.

Every data point is worthy of our attention, not just the one that supports your streaming case that happened to come in this matchup. I don’t think the Rams have a hole that Barner is uniquely qualified to exploit, and in that, I expect his recent production (2-4 catches for 30 yards) to be more predictive than the outlier from mid-November.

More Fantasy Football Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More Fantasy Articles

Ideal Fantasy Football Landing Spots For Top Rookies: Jeremiyah Love, Carnell Tate, and More

Six draft prospects could see instant fantasy upside if they fall into these realistic landing spots during the selection process.

Rookie TE Combine Comp Analysis: Kenyon Sadiq Looks Like This Classic 49ers Tight End

Oregon TE Kenyon Sadiq is a freak athlete, not unlike this legendary San Francisco 49ers TE. Should fantasy managers be excited?

Superflex Dynasty Rookie Rankings: Jeremiyah Love Leads An Underwhelming Class

With the combine and the bulk of free agency behind us, let's take a look at our latest top 24 dynasty rookie rankings.