Cleveland Browns tight end David Njoku has quietly established himself as one of the NFL’s most consistent pass-catching threats at his position. Yet, fantasy football managers continue to undervalue him heading into the 2025 season.
While industry experts debate which tight ends deserve top-tier consideration, data from PFSN’s Fantasy Football Mock Draft Simulator reveals Njoku deserves serious consideration as a potential fantasy value.
Consistent Production Despite Overlooked Status
PFSN users are drafting David Njoku nearly a full round earlier than the industry average, suggesting savvy fantasy managers recognize value others are missing. This discrepancy highlights a significant market inefficiency for a player who has delivered elite-level consistency over the past two seasons.
Njoku ranks among just four qualified tight ends to average five-plus catches per game over the past two seasons, placing him in exclusive company at a position known for inconsistent targets. His reliable hands and steady involvement in Cleveland’s passing attack have translated into dependable fantasy production that often goes unnoticed.
The first touchdown of Sunday belongs to David Njoku!! 👏 pic.twitter.com/G8TEzY52ul
— NFL Fantasy Football (@NFLFantasy) December 10, 2023
The touchdown production further strengthens Njoku’s case as an undervalued asset. His 0.41 touchdowns per game over the past two seasons trails only Mark Andrews, Sam LaPorta, and George Kittle, placing Njoku in the conversation with the position’s absolute elite. Still, his average draft position doesn’t reflect this level of red zone effectiveness.
Durability Concerns Don’t Tell Njoku’s Full Story
Despite missing six games in 2024, Njoku still managed to catch 60-plus passes and score five-plus touchdowns for the second consecutive season. Only Kittle and LaPorta have matched this achievement, underscoring Njoku’s ability to produce even when dealing with injury concerns.
The missed games might actually work in fantasy managers’ favor, as casual observers may remember the injury issues more clearly than the consistent production when healthy. This recency bias creates an opportunity for those willing to dig deeper into the numbers.
RELATED: Should I Draft David Njoku? Fantasy Outlook for the Browns TE in 2025
Cleveland’s offensive system under coordinator Ken Dorsey continues to utilize Njoku as a primary receiving option, particularly in crucial down-and-distance situations. His chemistry with QB Deshaun Watson has grown stronger each season, creating a foundation for continued success — giving other starters a trusted target.
Fantasy managers searching for late-round tight end value should strongly consider Njoku’s track record of consistent catches and red zone involvement. The combination of proven production, undervalued draft status, and continued offensive role makes him an ideal candidate to outperform expectations.
Sometimes the best fantasy assets are hiding in plain sight, producing quietly while others chase bigger names.
