Fantasy football is a game of inches. The difference between a touchdown stretch and a lost fumble resulting in a touchback is razor-thin. We often think of plays like that swinging entire matchups, but your fate could actually be decided before you even make your first selection.
If your league has a process for determining your draft slot, you need to make the most of it. You must think beyond just your first-round player—and that’s why I’m here. I’ve identified three specific draft slots that, if given the choice, I value above the rest for redraft leagues in 2026, and I’m happy to explain why.
Fantasy Football: Selecting Your Draft Slot
Optimal: Pick 1 or Pick 2
When it comes to this topic, your first reflex is the correct one.
I favor the top two spots for two simple reasons, neither of which is rocket science: you secure one of the absolute best players in the game right off the jump, and you gain immediate clarity on how a foundational roster spot is being filled.
Whether you prefer Jahmyr Gibbs or Bijan Robinson, you are guaranteed a fast start. I prefer the clarity of a top-two pick because it allows me to draft the rest of my team knowing my RB1 is already locked in. It removes a layer of uncertainty, and anytime I can limit the number of guesses I have to make, I take it.
START PREPARING: PFN’s Fantasy Mock Draft Simulator
Now that we have that out of the way, what does the rest of this team look like?
After landing your anchor running back, you will have to wait what feels like an eternity before picking again. You’ll watch all sorts of high-end talent come off the board—but not all of it. As the end of Round 2 approaches, there will still be three to five wide receivers available whom you could reasonably project as top-5 talents at the position. You should grab one of them.
And then, you should grab another.
- Malik Nabers: Finished as the WR6 as a rookie and features an even better supporting cast in 2026.
- Nico Collins: Has played at a 1,385-yard and 9-TD pace over 17 games since 2023.
- George Pickens: Coming off a career year in his first season with Dallas, setting personal bests in catches, targets, yards, and touchdowns.
- A.J. Brown: A premier vertical asset in a vertical offense (ranking second in aDOT last year) who enters the season with an axe to grind.
- Chris Olave: The clear WR1 in the fastest-moving offense in the NFL, paired with a developing quarterback.
While in-season management anchors far more fantasy championship stories than draft-day success, pairing two of these wideouts with a running back possessing generational upside creates a foundation few managers in your league will be able to match.
I don’t want to project your moves past the fifth round; we all know drafts have a way of going off-script well before then, making your ability to pivot paramount.
That said, there is a three-pack of players going in the Round 4-5 turn range that are circled and starred on my cheat sheets:
- Jaylen Waddle: The perfect fit in an upward-trending, highly creative offense under Sean Payton.
- Terry McLaurin: Combines a true alpha role with elite upside, provided Jayden Daniels takes the expected next step.
- D’Andre Swift: Featured prominently in my Top Fantasy Football Targets piece.
Every draft unfolds differently, but if your 12-team league breaks standard early ADP trends, it is a no-brainer to snag one of those top two draft slots if given the opportunity.
DIVE IN: PFN’s Fantasy Football HQ
Secondary Selection: Pick 5
I normally prefer picking at the turn. I am a control freak in life—not just in fantasy sports—and picking at the ends of rounds allows me to dictate the tempo, making two selections in a short window without worrying about chaos unfolding in between.
So, it should say a lot that I value the number-five spot as the next best option.
I agree with the consensus that the elite tier of fantasy assets contains exactly five players: Bijan Robinson, Jahmyr Gibbs, Puka Nacua, Ja’Marr Chase, and Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Shuffle them however you like, but that is the standard belief. If you pick fifth, you not only assure yourself a piece of that elite tier, but you also let the board make the tough decision for you.
You simply take whoever falls to you and move on (for me, that is often JSN).
In virtually every mock draft I’ve completed this summer, I have started with a wide receiver in this spot, which feels optimal. It sets up perfectly because I love the outlook of the running backs typically available on the board in Round 2.
If Chase Brown or Kenneth Walker III fall to you, click the draft button quickly and don’t look back. Both are attached to stable offenses under center with no real threats to their workloads. Brown is a versatile weapon in a Bengals offense that knows how to maximize his skill set, while the Chiefs brought in Walker after he proved what he can do on the sport’s biggest stages.
STAY UPDATED: PFN’s Fantasy News Tracker
I’d bet on at least one of them finishing the season as a top-5 performer at the position. With that level of upside, you can’t pass up securing a position that thins out incredibly fast.
If both are off the board, Jeremiah Love or Omarion Hampton serve as fantastic consolation prizes. Both are young backs with plenty to prove, but neither carries real volume concerns, and both profile as true professional difference-makers.
Round 3 is where you must begin mixing strategies. I feel comfortable going WR-RB if I hold the fifth selection, but you will need to read the room after that initial turn.
A.J. Brown and Chris Olave were noted above as potential Round 3 targets, and they have slid to the middle of the round in several drafts this summer. Rashee Rice is another wideout who commands interest in this range due to the high weekly floor his profile presents, assuming Patrick Mahomes remains healthy and Rice maintains his regular role on the field.
If those receiving options dry up before you’re on the clock, pivoting to a second running back is the move. Josh Jacobs has his own situation to navigate, but you will have more clarity on that by draft day. He has racked up 28 touchdowns and 72 receptions over his two seasons (32 games) with the Packers—production that is incredibly difficult to find once the top 20 players are off the board.
Javonte Williams is also highly likely to be staring you in the face here. The 2025 breakout star returns to the exact same role for an offense capable of putting up points in bunches.
Your choice in Round 3 will dictate your direction in Round 4, but the target names remain the same as above: target Waddle or Swift.
As you venture into Round 5, things get interesting, and your personal management style will dictate the path. A pair of Packers pass-catchers set to thrive following a wide receiver purge in Green Bay are firmly in play (Christian Watson and Tucker Kraft). You can also look at two young players coming off vastly different seasons, both of whom offer immense value relative to their current draft-day cost:
- Brian Thomas Jr.: Stat lines like his 87-1,282-10 rookie campaign don’t happen by accident.
- Tyler Warren: Played at a 1,000-yard pace through Week 12 last season despite dealing with poor touchdown luck.
At the end of the day, the decisions you make during the draft outweigh the slot you pull, and your in-season management matters most of all. However, because this is the very first decision of your 2026 fantasy season, you might as well make it a great one.
Looking to practice building out your roster? Our FREE Fantasy Football Mock Draft Simulator guides you through an entire draft in any format, helping you hone your skills ahead of the big day.
