The Buffalo Bills are entering a new era, with a new stadium on the horizon. General manager Brandon Beane is at the center of these changes, retaining quarterback Josh Allen as the team’s cornerstone while reshaping other aspects. In this context, an NFL analyst has provided insights on one of the team’s most significant personnel decisions of the offseason.
Buffalo Bills GM Brandon Beane Chided for DJ Moore Trade
This offseason, Beane led significant changes, including parting ways with head coach Sean McDermott and hiring Joe Brady as his replacement. Additionally, the team traded for DJ Moore, a move criticized by ESPN NFL analyst Bill Barnwell.
Barnwell remarked, “Every step of the Moore process felt like a franchise acting out of desperation. It’s clear the Bills were frustrated by their wide receivers in 2025. Under that lens, making a significant move for a receiver made sense. I’m just not sure this was the right one.”
While Moore had been one of Caleb Williams’ favorite targets in Chicago, trading for him might not provide Allen with the help he needs. For instance, Moore caught just 58.8% of his passes last year, and across his eight-season career, he has dropped 41 passes. Heading to Buffalo off an uneven season, Barnwell highlights these concerns.
“Moore is coming off what was comfortably his worst season as a pro, one in which he seemingly fell out of favor with Ben Johnson in the Chicago offense,” Barnwell said. During the Divisional Round, with the Bears on a potential game-winning drive against the Los Angeles Rams, Moore gave up on a route.
Williams expected Moore to keep going, throwing the ball to a spot. When he didn’t, Rams safety Kam Curl intercepted the ball, effectively ending the game for Chicago. Barnwell chastised the Bills for spending too much to complete the deal.
According to Barnwell, “This should have essentially been a salary dump scenario for Ryan Poles. Instead, the Bills sent a second-round pick to the Bears for Moore.” Now, the Bills are responsible for $49 million over the next two years, making Moore, due to his contract, a must-start player.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
Looking ahead, the Bills will pair Moore with Khalil Shakir, Keon Coleman, veterans Mecole Hardman and Joshua Palmer, and fourth-round pick Skyler Bell, who will round out the receiver group. Though Buffalo fielded the No. 3 offense in the league, according to PFSN’s NFL Offense Impact Metric, their postseason troubles continued.
Moore brings big-play ability but is occasionally inconsistent in route running and decision-making. On the positive side, Moore has so far recorded four 1,000-yard seasons in his career. Beane is willing to invest $49 million in him as the Bills aim for a Super Bowl appearance. Is this the right move?
