The Tampa Bay Buccaneers have a decision coming that could reshape how they operate at quarterback. Baker Mayfield has outplayed his deal, and now comes the challenge of putting a number on it.
Baker Mayfield Extension Talks Could Push Buccaneers Into Unfamiliar Territory
The upper-middle-class quarterback market remains fluid in the NFL. According to Jeff Howe of The Athletic, the Buccaneers are expected to discuss a contract extension with Mayfield this offseason, as his current deal runs through March 2027. However, the structure and expectations around that next deal are where things get complicated.
“Baker Mayfield’s three-year, $100 million deal expires in March 2027… but now that he has more than proven his worth as a franchise quarterback, don’t assume his next pact will remain among the most team-friendly in the NFL,” Howe wrote.
He went further, laying out what that next contract could look like and how those ranges shape the conversation. “Mayfield,” Howe wrote, “would be justified to ask for four years and $224 million or five years and $280 million, with at least half fully guaranteed.”
Mayfield has done enough to get paid. Now, it comes down to how aggressive the Buccaneers want to be. That has not always been the team’s approach.
The Buccaneers’ history at quarterback tells the story. Jameis Winston never reached a long-term second contract with the team. Tom Brady took a discount during the franchise’s Super Bowl window. Mayfield’s current deal came when he was still trying to reestablish himself.
This is the first time in years the organization is facing a quarterback who has earned a true market-setting deal. League-wide, that market continues to climb. The $50 million per year threshold is becoming standard for established starters, and Mayfield has positioned himself in that range.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
He turns 31 this offseason and, at one point in 2025, was in the middle of the MVP conversation as the Buccaneers started 6-2, including a win in Seattle against the eventual Super Bowl LX champion Seahawks. But the Bucs won only two games after that. Mayfield finished 24th in PFSN’s Quarterback Impact Metric.
Regardless, Mayfield has created some leverage. But the Buccaneers’ spending patterns suggest a more cautious approach. After ranking near the top of the league in cash spending during the Brady years, the Buccaneers have pulled back in recent seasons.
Fully guaranteed money must be placed in escrow, making cash a real factor. A contract at the top of the market is not just about value; it is about the willingness to structure it that way. There is also a broader question the organization has to answer: Is paying a quarterback at the very top of the market the best way to build the roster?
Teams around the league are still trying to figure that out. Some have fully committed, while others have started looking for alternatives. The Buccaneers sit in the middle of that decision. Mayfield has done enough to earn a significant raise. It is unclear whether the Buccaneers are ready to meet the price that comes with it.
