The fantasy football landscape shifts each week, bringing fresh opportunities and unexpected challenges that separate the prepared from the pretenders. Savvy managers know that last week’s performance tells only part of the story, and diving deeper into the underlying metrics reveals the accurate picture.
This week presents some intriguing decisions. Here’s insight about key Miami Dolphins players heading into their matchup with the Cincinnati Bengals to help you craft a winning lineup.
Tua Tagovailoa, QB
I’m not a big eye test guy, but if you thought that Tua Tagovailoa looked like the picture his numbers painted on Monday night (22-of-28 for 253 yards, two touchdowns, and one interception), we are coming at this from very different angles.
The interception was a fluttering pass in the first quarter. It kind of looked like the football weighed 10 pounds and Tagovailoa was trying to will it to the perimeter. Maybe that was a weather thing (17 degrees at kickoff in Pittsburgh, something that obviously won’t be the case this week), but it certainly wasn’t the first time we saw limitations on that front from Miami’s signal caller.
For the night, 86.1% of his fantasy production came when trailing by 14+ points, a situation that isn’t too likely to occur in this spot with the Bengals’ playoff hopes dashed last week.
If you want to go this direction in a top-heavy DFS contest, go nuts. Stack together five pieces from this game and have a ball. This game could hit in a big way, but for me, the downside potential is far too high if we are talking about the semifinals of your season-long league.
MORE: Fantasy Football Trade Analyzer
De’Von Achane, RB
That’s now seven straight games for De’Von Achane with 5+ catches or a rushing touchdown as he continues to put together a season that is going to land him in the first round of drafts in August.
The rib injury that he suffered in Week 14 showed no signs of slowing down Miami’s ace. Achane has 12+ PPR points in every single game this season and has cleared 16 in 13 of 14. Even in a game on Monday night where he failed to record a red zone touch for just the second time of the season, he was able to more than pay off your trust in him thanks to catching all six passes thrown his way (67 yards).
There is no game script that puts him at risk, and if this offense can take a step or two forward, he has the potential to lead the position in scoring next season.
MORE: Free Fantasy Waiver Wire Tool
Jaylen Wright, RB
One week after an impressive showing when filling in for a banged-up De’Von Achane, Jaylen Wright took the field for four snaps against the Steelers.
Who the backup is to Achane will be a worthwhile conversation this summer and something we need to sort out ahead of 2026 drafts, but for now, it’s clear that it doesn’t matter.
If you want to speculate on Achane being shut down, Wright over Ollie Gordon would be my lean, but that’s something we haven’t heard discussed.
Ollie Gordon II, RB
We can try to pin the tail on the backup Miami RB this summer as we look to protect the first-round investment on De’Von Achane, but at this point, there’s no need to be holding a Dolphin handcuff.
Ollie Gordon has handled more than five carries just three times this season, and the success has been limited at best (3.2 YPC). He suffered an ankle injury on Monday night, potentially paving the way for Jaylen Wright to finish this season as the secondary option, but that role hasn’t held value all year, and it’s too late to bet against Achane’s health.
MORE: Free Fantasy Start/Sit Lineup Optimizer
Jaylen Waddle, WR
I’m essentially not wanting to tie the fate of my fantasy season to the Dolphins (See Tagovailoa and Waller), but I’m OK backing Jaylen Waddle to bounce back from a slow stretch that has seen him be held to under 8.5 PPR points in three of his past four games.
Why can’t he be Week 15 Zay Flowers?
Baltimore’s clear-cut WR1 posted a 3-68-1 stat line in this matchup and left two big plays on the table with the two targets he saw not be completed (one a dropped pass and the other a misfire on what should have been a touchdown).
Waddle has six games this season with at least six targets AND a touchdown: if he checks either box, he’s likely to finish as a top-24 receiver, and if he checks both, a top-12 result could be within the cards. I’d rather play him than the aforementioned Flowers, but I’d also go as high up in the ranks to lean his way over the likes of George Pickens and Mike Evans.
Yeah, I said it.
READ MORE: Soppe’s Week 16 Fantasy Football Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Analysis for Every Player in Every Game
Darren Waller, TE
I understand that you’re staring at the big number from Darren Waller last week on your waiver wire and seeing the Cincinnati matchup this week.
I’d steer clear.
This Miami offense isn’t built to support pass catchers; it really is that simple. On Monday night, he saw 93% of his points come in the fourth quarter with the outcome no longer in doubt against the Steelers.
Waller wasn’t used meaningfully in the two weeks prior, and yes, while this is a great matchup, I’m not exactly comfortable with Tua Tagovailoa dictating whether I advance in my fantasy playoffs.
Waller sits outside of my top 10 tight ends for the week, and I’d ask you to take a second look at the waiver wire before settling on him (he may be the best available, but I wouldn’t blindly assume it).
