Super Bowl Picks and Predictions: Our Experts Share Their Super Bowl 58 Best Bets

What are our NFL betting experts' Super Bowl 58 picks and predictions as we break down how we see the biggest game of the year going?

We are just a matter of hours away from the start of Super Bowl 58, and it is time to get those bets in ahead of kickoff. We have seen plenty of action in the lines this week, but heading into Sunday morning, the 49ers remain favored anywhere between 1.5 and 2.5 across the various sportsbooks.

However, the spread is not the only action that you could consider this week, with thousands of prop bet options available. Ahead of the game between the San Francisco 49ers and Kansas City Chiefs, our NFL betting experts give their Super Bowl 58 picks and predictions.

Super Bowl 58 Odds and Betting Lines

Odds are from DraftKings and correct as of Saturday evening

  • Spread
    49ers -2 (-108)
  • Moneyline
    49ers -120, Chiefs +100
  • Total
    47.5

Chiefs vs. 49ers Predictions and Expert Picks

Rolfe: Everything I look at tells me that Super Bowl 58 will be a close game, but if one team does run away with it, it is more likely to be the Chiefs.

Based on that, I could just take the Chiefs getting their 1.5 or 2 points, but that leaves me vulnerable to a narrow 49ers win. Therefore, I am going to tease the result to give myself a margin of error.

You will not find many sportsbooks willing to let you get to Chiefs +7.5 without having to pay a major premium in terms of the odds. The beauty of Same Game Parlays is that you can pretty much pick the combinations you are happy with.

I have gone for Chiefs +7 and over 40.5 points because that is where I feel happiest. However, if you want to go Chiefs +7.5 and put the total somewhere different, that is very possible.

Pick: Chiefs +7 and Over 40.5 Points Scored (-120 at ESPN BET)

Bearman: Maybe people learned their lesson by now to not bet against Patrick Mahomes in the playoffs. Even when counted out, the Chiefs and Mahomes do their thing and are in their fourth Super Bowl over the last five years, something only done by two other franchises in the SB era.

Mahomes is now 10-1-1 against the spread (ATS) as an underdog, and he’s getting points again.

I’m not betting against last year’s champs, especially now that they have another weapon — their defense. What Steve Spagnuolo and Kansas City’s defense did to a Baltimore offense that was averaging 34 points per game, was tops in the NFL in rushing, and was led by presumptive MVP Lamar Jackson was nothing short of outstanding.

MORE: Super Bowl 58 Betting Analysis

Never before has Mahomes had a defense like this, which also shut down the Miami Dolphins and Buffalo Bills twice this season and held the Philadelphia Eagles to 21 points.

Great comebacks by the Niners vs. the Green Bay Packers in the Divisional Round and again vs. the Detroit Lions in the Conference Championship got them here. However, if that same San Francisco team we saw in the first half of both playoff games comes out in Las Vegas, the Chiefs will win easily.

I assume they will be ready, so we should have a good game. Four years ago, I predicted a 31-20 Kansas City win over the Niners, and I’m going back to the well with the same score.

Pick: Chiefs +2.5 (-125) and Moneyline (+100)

Soppe: This is the first of many different sorts of bets we will be detailing over the next 1.5 days and one that I feel good about jumping on now.

  • “No” has cashed in two of the three Mahomes Super Bowls
  • “No” has cashed in six of the past seven Super Bowls
  • Winner in eight of their past nine games
  • “No” has cashed in 15 of 20 Chiefs games this season

Just be careful in placing this bet, as the wording can vary by sportsbook. Some require you to bet “Yes” the first points will be scored at or after six minutes have elapsed. As long as you’re paying attention, this is a bet that carries more win equity than the odds suggest!

Pick: No Score in the First 6 Minutes (-135 at DraftKings)

Katz: There was a point during the season where the Chiefs had moved away from Marquez Valdes-Scantling entirely. Instead, Justin Watson was seeing increased playing time and running more routes. Recently, things have shifted back toward MVS as the WR2 ahead of Watson.

Watson’s snap share has been below 50% in each of the Chiefs’ past two playoff games. He hasn’t seen more than two targets in any of their three postseason contests, catching a total of three passes and never more than two in a game. Here’s to Watson having another game with exactly one reception.

Pick: Justin Watson Under 1.5 Receptions (-125 at DraftKings)

Soppe: The narrative heading into the Super Bowl is around the greatness of Mahomes and, of course, the presence of Taylor Swift. Overlooked, to a degree, is Isiah Pacheco, a player that I believe is set to impact this game as much as anyone.

The Panthers and Cardinals were two of the worst teams in the league this season; that much we can agree on, right? They combined to win six games and were rarely competitive down the stretch.

Well, those are the only two defenses with a lower rush EPA this season than the 49ers. We give Andy Reid plenty of credit for being an offensive genius, and I trust him holding my money in a bet like this as I am banking on him exploiting the primary weakness of his opponent.

Pacheco has carried the ball 15+ times in eight of his past nine games, and the lone exception was that loss on Christmas day against the Raiders that featured a pair of defensive touchdowns in seven seconds and 10 Mahomes rush attempts.

That game happened, but it’s not exactly something I’d call repeatable.

Pacheco has cleared this number in all three games this postseason, and that hasn’t happened by accident. Simply put, he gets harder to tackle with time. His yards gained per carry after contact are spiking, something we saw down the stretch of last season as well.

  • 2023: After Week 12, YPC after contact up 22.7%
  • 2022: After Week 14, YPC after contact up 21%

MORE: Here Are Some of the Biggest Super Bowl 58 Bets Made So Far

Given the point spread in this game, I don’t anticipate game script being a major issue — if we can pencil in Pacheco for 15+ totes in this one, I feel good about cashing this ticket.

Pick: Isiah Pacheco Over 67.5 Rushing Yards (-110 at FanDuel)

Our Betting Lines page has the freshest lines and promos to get BANG for your buck. PFN’s FREE Parlay Calculator and Betting Odds Calculator are also available for your betting process! New to sports betting? Check out our guide on How to Bet on the NFL. Visit our Sports Betting Legal Tracker on how to bet legally in the U.S.

Listen to the PFN Betting Podcast

Listen to the PFN Betting Podcast! Click the embedded player below to listen, or you can find the PFN Betting Podcast on iTunes, Spotify, and all major podcast platforms. Be sure to subscribe and leave us a five-star review!

Join the Conversation!

Related Articles