The margin for error was always thin. With a Super Bowl spot on the line, Jarrett Stidham’s first-half mistake flipped the AFC Championship Game and ignited instant backlash across the NFL world.
Denver’s emergency starter had been praised for his play early. Then one chaotic play shifted momentum, tied the game, and drew sharp reactions from former players who’ve lived through those moments.
A Single Play Changes the Tone in Denver
As the second quarter approached its midpoint, the Broncos were still in control. Then came the fateful mistake.
Under heavy pressure from Patriots linebacker Christian Elliss, Jarrett Stidham tried to throw the ball away. Instead, the pass traveled backward. New England recovered the loose ball inside the Denver 15.
Officials initially flagged the play as intentional grounding. Replay assist overturned that ruling, confirming it was a fumble. The Patriots were denied a defensive touchdown because the whistle blew early, but the damage remained. Two plays later, Drake Maye ran in a six-yard score to tie the game 7–7.
The sequence erased Denver’s early edge. And it shifted the narrative around Stidham almost instantly.
“A turnover would be catastrophic.” – Tony Romo right before a catastrophic turnover pic.twitter.com/QvvCNPGBN3
— NFL on CBS 🏈 (@NFLonCBS) January 25, 2026
Broncos legend Shannon Sharpe didn’t sugarcoat it on X: “Just don’t turn it over Stiddy. FCKK.”
Former NFL quarterback Kurt Benkert echoed it. “Stidham pulled a play out of Stroud’s book on that one,” Benkert wrote on X.
And Super Bowl champion Greg Jennings offered a blunt reminder of reality under pressure. “Why do QBs hate sacks so much? You’re not superhuman… Learn when the journey is over and take the sack,” Jennings said.
KEEP READING: 2026 7-Round NFL Mock Draft: Jets and Dolphins Select QBs of the Future, While 5 WRs Go in Round 1
Those reactions reflected a familiar postseason truth. Backup quarterbacks aren’t judged on volume. They’re judged on mistakes.
Stidham entered the game with less experience than any other conference championship backup. He’d played in just 20 NFL games, compared to Drew Lock, Josh Dobbs, and Jimmy Garoppolo, all of whom carry significantly more snaps and starts. That lack of live-game scar tissue showed in the moment Denver couldn’t afford it.
The irony is that Stidham had looked composed earlier. On the broadcast, Tony Romo praised him for “high-level stuff,” specifically calling out a play where Stidham looked off the Patriots’ coverage to move the chains. Sean Payton’s confidence was evident too, dialing up aggressive throws, including a 52-yard strike to Marvin Mims Jr. that beat Pro Bowl corner Christian Gonzalez.
But playoff football is unforgiving. One lapse can undo three good drives.
Denver had already passed on a short field goal earlier in the quarter. The fumble handed New England field position, points, and belief. Suddenly, the Broncos were no longer playing to their strengths.
Stidham isn’t done yet. But the standard changed in one snap. From a promising start to public scrutiny, the AFC Championship reminded everyone why experience matters and why mistakes echo loudest in January.
