The idea of a blockbuster trade involving one of the NFL’s most dominant defensive players has quickly captured attention across the league, as the Philadelphia Eagles look to maintain their place among the NFC’s elite. Bold roster moves are naturally part of the conversation.
Meanwhile, the Cleveland Browns find themselves in a far more uncertain position, balancing long-term planning with the presence of a generational talent. With the offseason heating up, speculation around Myles Garrett’s future has only intensified. Analysts are now beginning to explore scenarios that once felt unrealistic. And one proposed deal, in particular, has raised eyebrows for both its scale and implications.
Why a Myles Garrett Trade Proposal Could Cost the Eagles Massive Draft Capital
In a recent report, Fox Sports analyst Ralph Vacchiano outlined a potential trade framework that would send Garrett to Philadelphia. The proposed deal would see the Eagles part with huge draft capital, including a 2026 first-round pick, a third-round selection, and an additional first-round pick in 2027.
“It would be one of the biggest blockbusters in years, considering Garrett has won two of the past three Defensive Player of the Year awards, just set the single-season sack record, and is one year into a four-year, $160 million contract. Cleveland might not want to trade him, but what if the Eagles offered Jalen Carter as part of the package in return? Not crazy, considering Philly just signed defensive tackle Jordan Davis to a huge contract,” Vacchiano wrote.
Vacchiano also explored an alternative structure if Philadelphia chooses to keep its young defensive core intact.
“But if the Eagles prefer to keep Carter, then offering the Maxx Crosby package (two first-round picks) and a bit more should be valuable to a rebuilding team like the Browns who might not be good again soon. That’s a problem since Garrett is already 30. But he would instantly give Philly the pass rush it needs to return to the top of the NFC,” Vacchiano noted.
The proposal highlights both the cost and urgency behind such a move, especially for a team with championship aspirations. Garrett’s production explains why teams would even consider paying such a premium.
According to PFSN’s EDGE Impact Metric, he delivered a remarkable 95.6 score in 2025, earning an A grade and ranking No. 1 at his position. He recorded 23.0 sacks, 39 quarterback hits, and 60 total tackles, along with 33 tackles for loss and 37 splash plays, showcasing sheer dominance across every key category.
Despite that strong, historic output, Cleveland finished just 5-12 last season, underscoring the gap between individual strong showings and team success.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
But for Philadelphia, adding a player of that caliber to an already strong defense, one that ranked among the league’s best, would only elevate an already competitive unit into potentially the most feared defensive group in the league.
However, some hurdles remain, as Garrett’s no-trade clause means any deal would require his approval, while Cleveland must weigh whether moving a franchise cornerstone aligns with its rebuilding strategy.
This scenario ultimately comes down to timing and ambition. If the Eagles decide to push all their chips in, a move of this magnitude could reshape the NFC landscape.
