The Vegas Golden Knights have reached the Stanley Cup Final on the backs of contributions peppered throughout their lineup, but one player has attracted more outside attention than most. A year removed from a difficult exit from Toronto, Mitch Marner has become a central part of Vegas’ postseason success.
His resurgence has led to renewed discussion about how he was viewed in his previous market and how differently he is perceived today.
As the Golden Knights prepare for a championship showdown with the Carolina Hurricanes, one former Carolina star offered a measured perspective that pushed back against some of the louder narratives surrounding Vegas’ top scorer.
Mitch Marner Told Not to Expect Hostility in Carolina
The player at the center of this conversation is, of course, Mitch Marner, who enters the Stanley Cup Final leading all playoff scorers with 21 points in 16 games.
Marner’s postseason run has become one of the defining stories of the 2026 playoffs. After signing an 8-year, $96 million contract and moving to Vegas following a sign-and-trade from the Toronto Maple Leafs, he has helped transform the Golden Knights into a serious championship contender. His production has included seven goals, 14 assists, a team-leading plus-12 rating, and an NHL-best four shorthanded points.
These numbers have reignited debate about his years in Toronto, where he often faced criticism despite posting elite regular-season production. However, former Carolina Hurricanes captain Justin Williams chose not to engage in the criticism or revisit old grievances when asked about Marner.
Williams Pushes Back on Mitch Marner Criticism Ahead of Hurricanes-Golden Knights Final
During an appearance on TSN’s OverDrive, when the discussion turned toward Marner and the reaction he received during his Maple Leafs tenure, Williams immediately dismissed the idea of piling on.
“I don’t need jabs at anyone,” Williams said before recalling a recent conversation about fan reactions. “Reporter asked me, ‘Did people boo Mitch Marner?’ And I was like, ‘Why would people boo Mitch Marner?’ That seems very strange.”
Williams then shifted the focus to Marner’s talent and the challenge Carolina faces in the Final.
“But listen, he’s an elite player. He’s one of the best players in the league, and they’ve got a couple of them on that team that we’re really, really going to have to look at,” Williams said.
His comments stand out because they came from someone closely connected to the Hurricanes organization, ahead of a series in which Marner is expected to play a major role. Rather than embracing the criticism that often followed Marner in Toronto, Williams acknowledged both the player’s ability and the personal decisions he made throughout his career.
“I don’t blame him for wanting to stay with his team in Toronto. I don’t blame him for wanting to get out of there either,” Williams added.
The remarks align with a sentiment around the league that Marner’s playoff struggles in Toronto may have been overstated. In Vegas, he has thrived on a deeper roster, a balanced lineup, and a system that allows him to contribute in every situation.
Williams finished his assessment with a competitive reminder of where his loyalties remain.
“So right now, he’s looking great. He seems like he’s in a good situation. But I hope his season ends in heartbreak. Is that okay?”
ALSO READ: Golden Knights Chief Reveals Why Maple Leafs Failed to Make Mitch Marner Era Count
For Carolina, that remains the objective. For Marner, another strong series could complete one of the NHL’s most significant postseason turnarounds.
