Choosing the right goaltender is crucial for fantasy hockey success, as goalie performance often swings league outcomes from week to week. The following rankings highlight the most reliable options based on projected wins, save percentage, goals-against average, and shutout potential for the 2025-26 season. These goaltenders have been evaluated using both recent production and anticipated opportunity, ensuring fantasy managers can make informed draft-day decisions.
Make sure to also check out our overall Top 50 NHL fantasy rankings.
Who Are The Best Goalies to Draft in NHL Fantasy Leagues?
- Connor Hellebuyck, WPG
- Andrei Vasilevskiy, TBL
- Mackenzie Blackwood, COL
- Jake Oettinger, DAL
- Sergei Bobrovsky, FLA
- Logan Thompson, WSH
- Filip Gustavsson, MIN
- Darcy Kuemper, LAK
- Igor Shesterkin, NYR
- Anthony Stolarz, TOR
- Linus Ullmark, OTT
- Dustin Wolf, CGY
- Ilya Sorokin, NYI
- Frederik Andersen, CAR
- Jacob Markstrom, NJD
- Jordan Binnington, STL
- Adin Hill, VGK
- Sam Montembeault, MTL
- Joseph Woll, TOR
- Pyotr Kochetkov, CAR
- Lukas Dostal, ANA
- Jeremy Swayman, BOS
- Karel Vejmelka, UTA
- Juuse Saros, NSH
- Jet Greaves, CBJ
Draft These NHL Goalies in Fantasy
Connor Hellebuyck is widely viewed as the top goaltending option for the 2025-26 fantasy hockey season, cemented by his stellar consistency, high win total, and excellent save percentage. As the clear starter for Winnipeg, with proven Vezina-caliber credentials, Hellebuyck gives fantasy managers both a high floor and a tremendous ceiling in leagues that count wins, saves, and shutouts.
Andrei Vasilevskiy of Tampa Bay remains a perennial elite fantasy pick, known for his durability and ability to pile up wins behind a strong Lightning roster. Jake Oettinger in Dallas and Igor Shesterkin in New York also deserve early consideration, thanks to their roles as workhorse starters on contending clubs with sound defensive systems.
Beyond the established superstars, several rising and underrated goalies can provide league-winning upside. Mackenzie Blackwood, now with Colorado, is drawing buzz for his opportunity to start on one of the league’s best teams, potentially translating to a spike in wins and shutouts.
Filip Gustavsson (Minnesota) and Logan Thompson (Washington) offer sleeper potential, each poised for larger roles this season and a chance to outperform their draft slot if they seize their respective starting jobs. Securing at least one of these high-upside goaltenders in the middle rounds can solidify a fantasy roster’s foundation and take advantage of favorable team contexts throughout the year.
