The Toronto Maple Leafs have struggled to stay in the playoff race as results have slipped in recent weeks. The team sits outside a postseason spot and rarely stands a chance to qualify for the playoffs this season. Their overall play has been largely unimpressive, with defensive issues affecting most games.
Chris Pronger Criticizes Maple Leafs’ Reaction to Radko Gudas Hit
Auston Matthews will miss the rest of the 2025-26 season after suffering a serious knee injury during a game on March 12 against the Anaheim Ducks. The play involved a knee-on-knee collision with Radko Gudas, which resulted in a Grade 3 MCL tear and a quad contusion.
Matthews later underwent surgery on March 19 in New York, and the recovery timeline is around 12 weeks, which should have him ready for the next season.
The hit led to a five-game suspension for Gudas, but much of the focus has shifted to how Toronto reacted in that moment. Former Stanley Cup winner Chris Pronger shared his thoughts during an appearance on the “Nasty Knuckles” podcast and gave a clear view of what he noticed.
“If there was a camera on me, they would have thought I was a sick man. Because I started laughing when I saw the hit, because I looked at all the players. And I’m looking at, I’m literally staring at Gudas right here as I’m looking at the camera. I’m staring right at it, I see it happen, and I’m looking, and [Gudas] he’s looking around, he’s looking around, knowing, okay, somebody’s coming.
“And they all just, I’m like, what are we doing here, guys? And the worst part, not only did they not respond in that regard, they didn’t even go over and check on him. Yeah, they’re all so far away. The trainer was there, and they were gone. They didn’t even check on him. I’m like, wow, this is interesting.”
Pronger also spoke about what this could mean for the team moving forward and raised broader concerns about the group. “Well, that’s the huge $64 million question. What do they do? Do they blow it up? Do they fire everybody again? Do they add on the fringes? Do they trade one or two guys?
“Ultimately, that’s up to ownership. That’s an ownership decision of what direction do you want to take this? Because clearly, it’s going in the wrong direction. And that’s not the first time something like that has happened, where nothing has happened.
“And it’s not like, you guys know Chief (Craig Berube), it’s not like he’s not going in there going like, guys, you’ve got to protect one another. You’ve got to be together. There’s a bigger issue going on there than a coach’s messaging. And by the way, that’s not even a coach’s message. That’s a player message. That’s togetherness. That’s a team thing. There’s something bigger going on there that we don’t know about.”
READ MORE: Auston Matthews Sweepstakes Down to 3 Western Conference Teams
Toronto’s season has not matched last year’s level, as they sit at 31-29-13 and remain outside the playoff picture. The loss of Matthews, who had 53 points in 60 games, has made the situation more difficult. While the offense continues to produce, defensive play has been an issue, with the team allowing 3.49 goals per game.
As the season moves closer to its end, the Maple Leafs are not only dealing with results but also facing questions about their identity and response in key situations.
