Just days after trading franchise captain Brady Tkachuk to the Florida Panthers, new details continue to emerge about what happened behind the scenes in Ottawa.
While the blockbuster deal was driven in part by Tkachuk’s desire to join his brother Matthew in Florida, the fallout has revealed that the relationship between the captain and the Senators’ locker room may have been more strained than many realized.
Brady Tkachuk’s Senators Exit Gets More Complicated
Following the trade, NHL insider Renaud Lavoie reported that there was significant pressure on management to complete a deal. According to his sources, it wasn’t just the front office or Tkachuk pushing for a move; the locker room had also reached a point where players were no longer fighting to keep their captain.
That sentiment appeared to show up on social media.
When Tkachuk was traded, only Jake Sanderson publicly acknowledged the move, posting a simple Instagram Story that read: “Goat” and adding a heart emoji.
The contrast became more noticeable just days later. After the Senators signed defenseman Jordan Spence to a four-year extension worth $5 million annually through the 2029-30 season, several teammates immediately celebrated the news online.
Goaltender Linus Ullmark posted: “Let’s go Spenny babe!” Tim Stützle added: “LETS GOOOO.” Thomas Chabot wrote: “Here we go JJ.”
Drake Batherson joked: “Beer garden tab is yours this year fella!! Congrats man.” Fabian Zetterlund reacted with a heart emoji, while Shane Pinto wrote: “Work on those mitts filla.”
Jake Sanderson also shared the signing on his Instagram Story.
While social media reactions don’t tell the full story, the difference in teammates’ responses has fueled further speculation that the locker room had become divided before Tkachuk’s departure.
That lines up with comments from NHL insider Elliotte Friedman, who reported that tensions inside Ottawa’s dressing room escalated after February’s 4 Nations Face-Off and the 2026 Winter Olympics. Brady’s gold-medal run alongside brother Matthew Tkachuk with Team USA intensified speculation that the brothers wanted to eventually play together in the NHL.
According to Friedman, the constant rumors became a distraction, and as uncertainty surrounding Brady’s future grew, it reportedly created more distance between him and the rest of the locker room.
There has also been confusion over how Tkachuk’s trade request unfolded.
After the trade, Senators GM Steve Staios said Tkachuk asked to be moved roughly 10 days after Ottawa’s first-round playoff exit.
Tkachuk, however, described a different timeline. “It wasn’t an easy decision,” Tkachuk said. “It was something that I took a little bit more time than what’s been out there to make that decision, and it was a very hard decision.”
His comments immediately sparked discussion across the hockey world because they appeared to contradict Staios’ version of events.
ALSO READ: ‘He’s Not Available’: Canadiens’ Audacious Enquiry on NY Islanders’ $68,000,000 Center Turned Down
Whether it’s a difference in perspective or something deeper, Tkachuk’s exit continues to reveal new details about Ottawa’s reportedly fractured locker room.
