The Edmonton Oilers entered the offseason carrying frustration after another playoff disappointment, but a new debate surrounding Evan Bouchard has become one of the league’s biggest talking points after the NHL released its 2026 Norris Trophy finalists.
Despite producing one of the highest-scoring seasons by a defenseman in recent history, Bouchard was left outside the final top three.
The decision immediately led to backlash across the hockey world, especially as analysts and former players compared his production to the players who made the cut. While the Professional Hockey Writers Association leaned toward Cale Makar, Rasmus Dahlin, and Zach Werenski, many around the league questioned how Edmonton’s top blueliner failed to earn finalist recognition.
Evan Bouchard’s Stats Fuel Debate After 95-Point Season Ends Without Norris Nomination
Bouchard finished the 2025-26 season with 95 points in 82 games, leading all NHL defensemen in scoring while also posting a plus-25 rating and handling major penalty-kill responsibilities for Edmonton. His 33 power-play points anchored the Oilers’ top-ranked unit, while his overall offensive production surpassed every finalist by at least 14 points.
This statistical gap became the center of the reaction once the finalists were officially announced. NHL analyst Jesse Pollock reacted strongly on X, writing, “People can harp on Evan Bouchard all they want, but it is CRAZY that he was not even NOMINATED for the Norris after putting up a 95 point season.”
The criticism continued as veteran columnist Mark Spector pointed toward the historical significance of Bouchard’s season. Spector wrote, “Only nine defencemen in NHL history have had more points than Bouchard’s 95.”
He also highlighted Bouchard’s defensive workload, noting his blocked shots, penalty-kill usage, and plus-25 rating while adding, “Doesn’t mean he wins the Norris, but I had Bouchard as a Finalist.”
Several analysts also questioned whether reputation and voting tendencies influenced the final results more than raw production. Carlo Colaiacovo summed up that frustration directly by posting, “How is Bouchard not even nominated?”
At the same time, some voters acknowledged how difficult this year’s race became because of the depth across the position. The Athletic’s Thomas Drance explained that the ballot created impossible choices between elite candidates. “If you wanted to recognize the finalists while also voting for Moritz Seider, that meant excluding 2 of Bouchard, [Quinn] Hughes, and [Lane] Hutson. Gut wrenching,” Drance wrote.
Even neutral observers found the omission surprising, considering Bouchard’s overall season. NHL analyst Drew Livingstone posted, “Bouchard didn’t even get nominated!? That’s insane, I’m not even an Oilers fan and think that’s ludicrous.”
Although Bouchard admitted he was “definitely upset a little bit” after hearing the news, he also made clear that his focus remains on team success moving forward.
ALSO READ: Oilers Trade Rumors: Maple Leafs’ $60,000,000 Blueliner Named Among Targets But There’s 1 Problem
