Facebook Pixel

    NFL General Manager Rankings: Belichick, Roseman and Ballard top list

    NFL General Managers New York Giants Dave Gettleman
    Dave Gettleman (Photo Credit: USA Today)

    32. TBD – Houston Texans 

    It’s hard for a team to have a bad general manager when no one is sitting in the chair. Brian Gaine’s recent firing comes with mixed reviews. He found three potential franchise pieces in 2018 before watching the team self-implode this offseason. Houston has an opening, making them dead last in our rankings.

    31. Joe Douglas – New York Jets 

    Joe Douglas is a fine executive who has been a hot name over the past two seasons. It’s hard to judge a GM when they haven’t done anything. Let’s check back in next year on the Jets’ newest member and see how he turns out.

    30. Jason Licht – Tampa Bay Buccaneers 

    I bet a ton of you were thinking Dave Gettleman was going to be ranked as the worst GM. Wrong! There’s one whose seat is hotter than the suicide hot wings in New York. Just trust me, they’re hot and don’t try the challenge.

    Since taking over, Licht’s Buccaneers still have yet to make the playoffs. That’s all in the past though since the long-time GM’s tenure should be based off this season. With the hiring of Bruce Arians, the Bucs could turn over a new leaf and end up being a competitive unit for years to come.

    The real story is that Arians was brought in to fix Jameis Winston. Struggling the past two seasons, the quarterback whisperer will need to see improvement from the former Heisman Trophy Winner if he expects to stay under center much longer. If Winston struggles again, both he and Licht could be looking for work come Black Monday.

    29. Dave Gettleman – New York Giants 

    Dave Gettleman let Landon Collins walk to division rival Washington and traded Odell Beckham Jr. for a first-round pick, a third-round pick, and Jabrill Peppers. Peppers isn’t atrocious, but he’s not Collins by any means. The first-round pick acquired from the Beckham trade turned into Dexter Lawrence when high-regarded pass rushers were still available.

    Let’s take a walk on the deep end, shall we? Give some credit to Gettleman for mustering up the courage to shock the world on draft night with Daniel Jones. Is it likely going to backfire? Yeah. Should Giants fans have their doubts? Undeniably. If Gettleman proved anything with the sixth selection, it is that you should take the guy you genuinely believe in. He did just that – so salute to you, bossman.

    Who knows, maybe Dave is from the future and has a diabolical plan to make Jones the MVP in 2020? Or perhaps he’s not cut out to be a GM and should let others make the decisions? We’ll check back in two years on this one; you know if he’s still in the seat and not on a crazy planet.

    2026 NFL Mock Draft Simulator

    The PFSN Mock Draft Simulator features hundreds of prospects, scouting reports, and free trades -- jump into the mock draft machine and get ready for the 2026 NFL Draft.

    2026 NFL Draft Big Board Builder

    PFSN’s free NFL Draft Big Board Builder allows you to rank every prospect in the NFL Draft and share it with the world.

    2025 NFL Playoff Predictor

    PFSN's 2025 NFL Season and Playoff Predictor is a tool that allows you to play out various weekly scenarios to see how the NFL playoff picture changes with each scenario.

    NFL Offseason Manager

    Do you think you can manage your favorite team’s roster better than the real-life general managers? PFN's Offseason Manager is here to help you prove it.

    Shedeur Sanders Gets 100% Real on His Relationship With Dillon Gabriel As Browns Rookies Fight To Become QB1

    As Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel compete for the Cleveland Browns' QB1 spot, they are showing mutual respect to each other.

    Colts DB Lists 6 Players, Including Lamar Jackson, Who Could Help USA Win Gold in Flag Football at 2028 Olympics

    With flag football coming to the 2028 Olympics, one Indianapolis Colts has the perfect roster in mind featuring speedsters like Lamar Jackson.

    Super Bowl MVP Jalen Hurts Makes His Feelings Known About Nick Sirianni’s Contract Extension

    Jalen Hurts praises Eagles HC Nick Sirianni after his contract extension, highlighting shared growth and success following Philadelphia’s dominant Super Bowl victory.

    NFL Analyst Claims Saquon Barkley Will Have ‘40 Touchdowns Next Year’ if League Bans Eagles’ Tush Push Play

    NFL analyst Kyle Brandt says banning the tush push will only fuel the Eagles, predicting Saquon Barkley could score 40 touchdowns with added motivation and talent.
    Join the Conversation!

    1 COMMENT

    Comments are closed.