New York’s backfield situation continues evolving as Tyrone Tracy Jr. and Devin Singletary navigate a volatile committee approach. Both runners enter Week 11 following underwhelming performances that have fantasy managers questioning their reliability. Can fantasy football managers trust either Giants runner this week?
Tyrone Tracy Jr. Fantasy Outlook
Tracy has now operated as the lead back for three consecutive weeks. Last week produced his best fantasy outing of that stretch with 8.1 points, though that number is hardly encouraging for managers seeking consistent production. Tracy played 68% of the snaps against Chicago, a significant shift from playing behind Singletary the previous week.
The increased snap share didn’t manifest into better production despite the expanded opportunity. Tracy rushed 14 times for 71 yards while adding one reception for no yards. The efficiency remains mediocre at 3.9 yards per carry on the season, but that’s much better than Singletary’s 3.3 ypc.
MORE: Free Fantasy Football Start/Sit Optimizer
Tracy remains the superior talent to Singletary given his explosiveness and big-play ability. However, the recent results don’t inspire confidence in his weekly floor. Tracy out-touched Singletary 15 to 11 last week but still produced fewer fantasy points than his backfield partner.
The sophomore is seeing neither enough snaps nor volume to be trustworthy in fantasy lineups at this stage. Tracy likely will see 55-65% of team snaps on a weekly basis moving forward, but that level of involvement hasn’t translated to reliable fantasy production. The workload distribution remains volatile from week to week, creating lineup uncertainty.
Devin Singletary Fantasy Outlook
Singletary hasn’t been much better than Tracy with 10.3 and 7.1 fantasy points over the past two weeks. However, both of those numbers exceeded Tracy’s production in the same contests. Even with Singletary’s snap share dropping to 31% against the Bears, he still managed to be the better fantasy option.
The veteran’s ability to outproduce Tracy despite significantly fewer snaps raises questions about the rookie’s efficiency. Singletary posted a 3-for-53 receiving line last week that salvaged his fantasy day despite minimal rushing involvement. Despite Tracy being the superior receiver, Singletary’ss pass-catching ability has provided PPR value that Tracy hasn’t consistently delivered.
READ MORE: Soppe’s Week 10 Fantasy Football Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Analysis for Every Player in Every Game
Singletary has carved out a meaningful role that extends beyond simple backup duties. The former Bills runner will see 20-40 rushing yards per game moving forward while catching less than one ball per contest. That limited volume severely caps his weekly ceiling in most game scripts.
Should You Start Tracy or Singletary This Week?
Green Bay presents a challenging matchup for New York’s rushing attack. The Packers allow the fifth-fewest schedule-adjusted fantasy points per game to running backs, creating difficult conditions for both backs.
The matchup this week is an interesting one from a game environment perspective. Jameis Winston is starting at quarterback with Jaxson Dart in the concussion protocol. That’s not great for the Giants because Winston is a turnover machine, but his offenses are not lacking for scoring. The Giants could find themselves near the goal line plenty of times.
Winston won’t take touchdown opportunities from his running backs the way Dart does with his dual-threat ability. This creates potential scoring chances for both backs if New York can generate red zone opportunities. However, the Packers’ elite run defense and likely negative game script work against sustainable rushing volume.
Fantasy managers should try to find alternatives for Week 11. Tracy remains the superior option despite recent production struggles, projecting as a low-end RB2 with volatile week-to-week outcomes. Singletary functions as a handcuff worth stashing but offers minimal standalone value. Neither back possesses a particularly high ceiling this week against Green Bay’s stout defensive front.