The Buffalo Bills’ wide receiver rotation continues to present difficulties for fantasy football managers seeking reliable production from this group. Khalil Shakir, Keon Coleman, and Joshua Palmer each offer different skill sets and roles within Buffalo’s offense, but none has established themselves as a weekly must-start option. How should fantasy managers handle this WR room in Week 2 against the New York Jets?
Khalil Shakir Fantasy Outlook
Shakir entered Week 1 as the Bills’ most reliable receiver option and delivered a solid floor performance, catching 6 of 9 targets for 64 yards while posting 12.4 fantasy points. His slot-heavy role provides consistency within Buffalo’s spread-the-wealth passing attack.
The veteran lined up primarily out of the slot and ran more slot routes than any wide receiver in Week 1, cementing his role as Buffalo’s primary underneath option. This positioning gives him the most reliable target floor among the team’s receivers, though it limits his ceiling in terms of explosive plays.
— Film Collins (@filmcollins01) September 8, 2025
Against the Jets’ defense, Shakir should find opportunities working from the slot. New York’s secondary struggled in Week 1 against Pittsburgh’s passing attack, allowing 278 passing yards and multiple big plays to various receivers throughout the contest.
His high ankle sprain from training camp appeared to be a non-factor in the opener, as he moved well and showed no apparent signs of limitations. This health improvement provides optimism for his continued reliability moving forward.
Keon Coleman Fantasy Outlook
Coleman delivered the breakout performance many hoped for in Week 1, leading the Bills in routes run. His 25.2 fantasy points represented a massive leap from his rookie struggles and provided hope for continued development. His 44 route runs led all Bills receivers and suggested an expanded role.
The second-year receiver demonstrated improved reliability despite still lacking elite separation skills. His eight catches on 11 targets for 112 yards and a touchdown proved that if defenses give him a cushion, Coleman can capitalize effectively on his opportunities.
It’s only one game, but #Bills WR Keon Coleman’s usage in Week 1 was VERY encouraging. pic.twitter.com/8Vl9VxAxsX
— Marcus Mosher (@Marcus_Mosher) September 9, 2025
Coleman’s skill set bears similarities to DK Metcalf, who gave the Jets secondary problems in Week 1. While Metcalf is clearly a superior talent, both receivers rely on size and contested-catch ability rather than pure separation to create production, suggesting Coleman could succeed against New York’s coverage.
However, Coleman’s success may depend heavily on matchup specifics. The Bills are not going to move him around the formation. Given the Jets’ cornerbacks’ elite press coverage skills, if he encounters too much coverage from Sauce Gardner, it could result in a difficult afternoon.
Joshua Palmer Fantasy Outlook
Palmer provided a reliable floor in Week 1, matching Shakir’s nine targets while posting a 5-61 receiving line for 11.1 fantasy points. However, his usage patterns raise concerns about his consistency and role within the offense.
The veteran is clearly not Buffalo’s primary X receiver, as evidenced by playing fewer snaps and running fewer routes than Shakir and Coleman. His target total likely benefited from the Bills being forced to throw 46 times due to negative game script throughout the contest.
Palmer’s production came almost entirely in the second half with Buffalo trailing, as he managed just one catch for four yards in the first half. This game-script dependency makes him unreliable for weekly fantasy use, particularly against teams that shouldn’t force the Bills into catch-up mode.
The Jets looked impressive offensively in Week 1, but it’s unlikely they can force Buffalo into the same negative game script that created Palmer’s opportunities.
His role appears more complementary than essential, making him a poor bet for consistent weekly production. The veteran’s 12.2-yard average per reception suggests some big-play ability, but his limited route-running and snap count cap his ceiling significantly.
Should You Start Shakir, Coleman or Palmer This Week?
Fantasy managers must remember that Josh Allen won’t attempt 46 passes every week like he did in the epic 41-40 victory over Baltimore. The Bills were in a negative game script throughout that contest, and most weeks, the same high-volume passing attack that benefited all receivers will not be used.
MORE: Free Fantasy Football Start/Sit Optimizer
Most games won’t provide enough volume or scoring opportunities for all three Bills wide receivers to return meaningful fantasy value. The team’s balanced offensive approach limits individual receiver ceilings while providing modest floors for the primary options.
Shakir remains the safest and best option for fantasy purposes among this group. His slot role provides the most reliable target floor, and his proven chemistry with Allen makes him the most trustworthy weekly play despite his limited ceiling.
Coleman presents the most volatility but also the highest upside potential. If his Week 1 performance represents him turning a corner, he has the talent and size to emerge as Buffalo’s true WR1 and weekly fantasy starter.
Palmer functions primarily as a floor player but is best left on benches outside deep leagues. His game-script dependency and limited role make him unsuitable for consistent weekly use, particularly in matchups where Buffalo should control the game flow.
