The Cincinnati Bengals’ playoff hopes remain in jeopardy as their franchise quarterback continues his long road back from a devastating injury. Joe Burrow has now missed eight weeks with a severe turf toe injury that required surgery. With the Bengals’ playoff chances dwindling, will fantasy football managers see Burrow back on the field this season?
Joe Burrow Injury Update
An awkward tackle while attempting to escape pressure during Cincinnati’s Week 2 victory over Jacksonville left Burrow with the injury. Medical professionals diagnosed a Grade 3 turf toe injury and projected a minimum three-month recovery period.​
Dr. Norman Waldrop at Birmingham’s Andrews Sports Medicine and Orthopedic Center performed the surgical repair. The diagnosis represents the most severe classification of turf toe, indicating complete tears of all soft tissues in the big toe including both ligaments and the joint capsule.​
Cincinnati officially opened Burrow’s 21-day practice window last week, permitting Burrow to participate in limited on-field activities without occupying a spot on the 53-man roster.​​
Limited participation began Monday as part of his recovery progression from the toe injury. This development signals meaningful advancement and suggests he’s moving toward a potential comeback. The organization now faces a 21-day deadline to either activate him to the active roster or place him on season-ending injured reserve.​
The decision to open his practice window appears curious given Cincinnati’s near-zero playoff probability. Entering Week 12 at 3-7 following another defeat to Pittsburgh, the Bengals can essentially afford no additional losses to maintain realistic postseason hopes. Their playoff probability has collapsed into the low single digits.
Burrow maintains his plan to return in Week 13 or 14, which strikes many as incredibly aggressive considering initial projections placed his earliest potential comeback in mid-December. The team’s Thanksgiving Day showdown in Week 13 against Baltimore represents his target date, with Burrow calling it “very meaningful” when asked about returning for that prime-time divisional clash.​
Burrow certainly desires to play regardless of Cincinnati’s record. However, if the Bengals stand at 4-7 or 3-8 heading into Week 13, having Burrow risk his health seems imprudent.​
Nevertheless, mathematical playoff elimination won’t occur even with losses in their next two contests. All indications suggest Burrow intends to return. Remains to be seen whether that actually happens if the Bengals are no longer in playoff contention.​
One certainty exists: Burrow must either receive activation by Week 14 or revert to season-ending injured reserve once the 21-day practice window expires. The team faces a mandatory decision at that juncture.​​
Burrow Fantasy Outlook
Fantasy managers are cautioned against getting overly excited about this unexpectedly positive news. Even in the best-case scenario with a Week 13 comeback, the Bengals would be one loss away from mathematical playoff elimination. It is very plausible that the moment they are done, Burrow is too.
RELATED: Free Fantasy Football Start/Sit Optimizer
In Burrow’s absence, the Bengals have utilized veteran quarterback Joe Flacco, whom they acquired in a trade from the Cleveland Browns. Flacco led the team to a victory in Week 7 against divisional rival Pittsburgh, but has not won another game.
The opening of Burrow’s practice window provides a glimmer of hope, but the overwhelming likelihood is that fantasy managers won’t see meaningful production from Burrow in 2025. The combination of Cincinnati’s dismal playoff odds and the aggressive nature of the return timeline makes him a highly risky proposition for fantasy purposes.
