Kickers may not always get the draft-day spotlight, but the right one can be the difference in tight fantasy football matchups. Consistency, team scoring volume, and long-range ability all factor into which kickers provide the most value. In 2025, fantasy managers have an interesting mix of elite options such as Brandon Aubrey, Jake Bates, and Evan McPherson, along with steady veterans like Harrison Butker and Jake Elliott, who continue to anchor playoff-caliber offenses.
We break down the top 20 fantasy kickers, their outlooks, and where to prioritize them in your drafts.
For more information surrounding the top fantasy options, make sure to check out our recent fantasy outlooks for 150+ players.Â
Which Kicker Should You Draft in Fantasy Football?
1) Brandon Aubrey | Dallas Cowboys
2) Jake Bates | Detroit Lions
3) Evan McPherson | Cincinnati Bengals
4) Cameron Dicker | Los Angeles Chargers
5) Chris Boswell | Pittsburgh Steelers
6) Wil Lutz | Denver Broncos
7) Ka’imi Fairbairn | Houston Texans
8) Chase McLaughlin | Tampa Bay Buccaneers
9) Jake Elliott | Philadelphia Eagles
10) Harrison Butker | Kansas City Chiefs
11) Jason Sanders | Miami Dolphins
12) Tyler Bass | Buffalo Bills
13) Matt Gay | Washington Commanders
14) Joshua Karty | Los Angeles Rams
15) Tyler Loop | Baltimore Ravens
16) Younghoe Koo | Atlanta Falcons
17) Jason Myers | Seattle Seahawks
18) Cam Little | Jacksonville Jaguars
19) Daniel Carlson | Las Vegas Raiders
20) Cairo Santos | Chicago Bears
Harrison Butker, Kansas City Chiefs
Harrison Butker remains a reliable fantasy kicking option heading into 2025, backed by renewed optimism in the Kansas City Chiefs’ offense. After missing four games in 2024 due to a knee injury, Butker still converted 21 of 25 field-goal attempts (84%) and 29 of 31 extra points. Three of his misses came from 50+ yards, so accuracy inside that range is not a concern.
With Patrick Mahomes and a healthier receiving corps set to boost Kansas City’s scoring above last year’s 22.6 points per game, Butker could see increased opportunities. As one of the league’s most accurate kickers, he offers a stable floor and top-five upside if the Chiefs regain their offensive spark.
Evan McPherson, Cincinnati Bengals
Evan McPherson is poised for fantasy football relevance this year as the Bengals’ kicker, supported by an offense capable of generating scoring opportunities and backed by a lucrative three-year contract extension that shows the team’s confidence in his abilities. While he has faced some regression in accuracy and a groin injury, McPherson’s big leg and history of clutch kicks still put him among the top 10 options for fantasy rosters, especially in leagues where kickers can swing matchups with long-range field goals.
Even though McPherson plays almost exclusively outdoors, which presents some weather-related risk, he has made over 83% of his kicks since joining the league and rarely misses extra points. With star quarterback Joe Burrow healthy and leading the Bengals’ offense, McPherson should see plenty of opportunities to score, making him a smart late-round pick for managers seeking upside and reliability at the kicker position.
