NFL Legend Eli Manning Shares Hilarious Details About Working With ‘Psycho’ Peyton Manning Post Retirement

Eli Manning recently appeared on the Glue Guys Podcast, joining Ravi Gupta, Alex Smith, and Shane Battier for a wide-ranging conversation. What began as a heartfelt discussion on family dynamics soon turned into a hilarious recounting of Peyton Manning’s over-the-top preparation methods. But Eli also reflected on career-defining moments, including one of the most unforgettable upsets in Super Bowl history.

Eli Manning Opens Up About Peyton Manning’s Obsessive Prep Habits

While speaking about their bond, Eli credited the Manning brothers’ ability to poke fun at each other without taking it personally. The former Giants quarterback laughed about Peyton’s famously intense habits.
“Peyton knows that he’s, like, a psycho a little bit on his prep,” Eli said. The stories didn’t stop there. Peyton, instead of making normal phone calls or leaving voicemails, sends lengthy voice recordings.
“He left me a voice memo today, like a six-minute… not a voicemail,” Eli explained. “But when you do, like, a game plan, Alex, he’ll leave me a 35-minute voice memo.”

That kind of detail might work in film rooms, but Eli didn’t hesitate to joke about it. “Just send me the CliffsNotes,” he texted back. “Need CliffsNotes of the 35-minute voicemail, not listening.” According to Eli, it would be faster to watch the tape himself than to sit through Peyton’s audio breakdowns.
Shane Battier chimed in, defending Peyton’s thoroughness. “You can never be too thorough, Eli.”

Eli responded with appreciation, saying, “And it’s good. And I appreciate and it’s what made him so good.”
Beyond the brotherly banter, Eli also shared his awe at winning Super Bowl XLII. The Giants had finished the regular season with a modest record, but something shifted in early 2008. Leading up to the Super Bowl, New York had already given the undefeated Patriots a serious challenge. Though they lost that game, it gave the team renewed belief.
During their game against New England, Manning made one of the most iconic plays in NFL history. On third-and-five, under intense pressure, Manning evaded Ty Warren and launched a deep pass that David Tyree famously caught against his helmet. Just minutes later, Manning found Plaxico Burress for the game-winning touchdown.
“My teammates are all pretty young,” Manning said. “You feel like you’re on top of the world with some of your best friends.”
The Giants’ 17-14 victory shattered the Patriots’ perfect season and changed the narrative around Manning’s career. He would later add another Super Bowl win over the same team. Despite finishing his career with an even 117-117 record, Manning’s place in NFL history was already secure.
What started as tales of sibling quirks evolved into a reminder of Eli’s clutch legacy – a story of grit, timing, and a touch of disbelief that never quite left him.