The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback room was always going to be messy, but this is a full-blown offseason curveball. Just when it felt like the franchise was inching toward a youth-driven reset, the conversation has flipped back to Deshaun Watson.
Why Deshaun Watson Is Reportedly Leading the Browns’ QB1 Race
And it’s not sitting well with everyone. Analysts around the Browns ecosystem are raising eyebrows as reports suggest Watson isn’t just in the mix; he’s actually leading the race. For a team trying to turn the page, that narrative feels complicated at best.
During discussions surrounding the Browns’ quarterback battle, ESPN analyst Chris Oldach pushed back hard on the idea of Watson leading the depth chart. His stance was simple: Stop overthinking it and let the young guy cook.
“I’d much rather just let Shedeur have the necessary reps, see what you have,” Oldach said.
“I’d much rather just let Shedeur have the necessary reps, see what you have,” – @TheOGPAW on the report that Deshaun Watson has the “pole position” to start week 1.
Do you agree? https://t.co/tH9BokWGTV pic.twitter.com/4dwnJrBgei
— ESPN Cleveland (@ESPNCleveland) March 29, 2026
That frustration comes right as NFL Network insider Mike Garafolo reported, via “Good Morning Football,” that Watson is currently in “pole position” to start Week 1. The update, coming in late March 2026, adds a surprising twist to a competition that was widely expected to lean toward Shedeur Sanders after his late-2025 run.
Garafolo’s reasoning was layered. The Browns are still financially tied to Watson’s fully guaranteed $230 million deal.
There’s also an internal belief that his athletic profile fits head coach Todd Monken’s system. And yes, his peak years with the Houston Texans still carry weight in evaluation rooms, even if they feel like a lifetime ago.
But here’s where things get tricky. Watson’s tenure with the Browns hasn’t just underwhelmed; it’s been derailed.
He’s appeared in only 19 games across multiple seasons, battled suspensions, and missed the 2025 season following two surgeries to repair a re-ruptured Achilles tendon. Since joining the Browns, he has posted a 61.2% completion rate with 19 touchdowns and 12 interceptions.
Meanwhile, Sanders quietly built momentum. He started seven games during the final stretch of the 2025 season and showed flashes that hinted at long-term upside, finishing with 1,400 passing yards, 7 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions.
That’s exactly why voices like Oldach are questioning the logic. If the future is already in the building, why stall the process?
Still, the Browns’ approach seems calculated. Keeping Watson engaged matters, whether as a legitimate starter or a high-priced insurance policy. At the same time, labeling the job “wide open” ensures Sanders doesn’t coast into 2026 thinking it’s handed to him.
There’s also the reality of optics versus operations. Coaches haven’t seen live reps this offseason yet.
Evaluations right now lean heavily on past tape, internal beliefs, and projection. That leaves room for narratives like Watson’s “upside” to return to the spotlight.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
Monken has already hinted he’d prefer clarity by training camp, but even he admitted that timeline might be optimistic. This battle isn’t ending anytime soon.
So here we are. A quarterback who hasn’t consistently played in years is leading the race. A promising young starter is being asked to prove it again. And a franchise stuck between past investment and future potential is trying to make it all make sense. For the Browns, the QB drama never really left; it just found a new storyline.
