The hype surrounding Arch Manning has evolved from curiosity to growing anticipation as the Texas Longhorns gear up for a pivotal season. One analyst recently drew comparisons to Tim Tebow, a quarterback celebrated for both his talent and leadership. Now a redshirt sophomore, Manning is drawing attention for his skill set, athleticism, and composure.
With Manning stepping into the spotlight, expectations are sky-high. Fans and analysts alike are eager to see whether he can live up to the hype and emerge as one of college football’s top stars. This season will be a defining one, either cementing his rise or exposing the weight of expectation.
Paul Finebaum Says Arch Manning Is College Football’s Top QB Since Tebow
ESPN’s Paul Finebaum has established high expectations for Arch Manning as the season approaches. Speaking on Get Up, Finebaum expressed his view of Manning as a unique talent capable of leading Texas to national title contention. He even said Manning could win the Heisman by year’s end.
“The expectations are through the absolute roof… Arch Manning is the best college football quarterback we have seen since Tim Tebow entered the scene in 2006,” Finebaum declared. With such high praise, Manning will be under intense scrutiny to live up to the hype.
“Arch Manning is the best college football quarterback we have seen since Tim Tebow entered the scene in 2006.”
—@finebaum on Arch Manning 👀 pic.twitter.com/vTm9buTfKX
— Get Up (@GetUpESPN) July 1, 2025
During the 2023 season, Manning saw limited action, appearing in just three games for the Texas Longhorns. He completed 2 of 5 passes (40%) for 30 yards, averaging 6.0 yards per attempt, with no touchdowns or interceptions. On the ground, he added 7 yards on 3 carries (2.3 yards per carry), also without a score. Despite the small sample size, he offered glimpses of his potential.
In 2024, Manning stepped into a larger role and showed marked improvement. He completed 61 of 90 passes (67.8%) for 939 yards, averaging an impressive 10.4 yards per attempt.
KEEP READING: North Carolina Reshapes Athletic Department With Eye-Catching Succession Plan as Bill Belichick Buzz Continues
Manning threw for nine touchdowns and just two interceptions in 2024, highlighted by a 75-yard completion. His strong play earned him a 184.0 passer rating, signaling he’s ready for the starting role. On the ground, he added 108 yards on 25 carries (4.3 yards per attempt) and scored four rushing touchdowns, showcasing his versatility as a true dual-threat quarterback.
Texas coach Steve Sarkisian has publicly said Manning is ready to take over as the starting quarterback in 2025. Reports from spring practice indicate continued growth in his decision-making and mechanics.
Unlike many quarterbacks who transfer in search of playing time, Manning stayed at Texas and patiently waited for his opportunity, demonstrating maturity and commitment. Now, with the Longhorns ranked in the top five entering the season, he stands at the center of their national title hopes.
If Manning lives up to expectations, he could emerge as a serious Heisman Trophy contender. But if he falters, the spotlight could quickly turn critical. This season will determine whether Manning becomes college football’s next star, or another high-profile name who failed to deliver.
