Former Scout Hands Tough Verdict As Carson Beck’s NFL Stock Slips After CFP Title Loss

Former NFL scout John Middlekauff predicted that Carson Beck would slide to the third day in the 2026 NFL Draft.

Miami quarterback Carson Beck’s college football career ended on a sour note when his attempted heave to tie the national championship game was picked off by Indiana defensive back Jamari Sharpe to end the contest. Beck finished the 27-21 loss to the No. 1 Hoosiers with 232 passing yards, one touchdown, and a costly interception.

Beck had left the Georgia Bulldogs under a cloud last year in a bid to improve his flagging draft stock after a shaky season under center in Athens, and for long stretches of the season, he looked capable of dragging the No. 10 Hurricanes to glory.

PFSN 2026-2027 CFB Playoff Predictor
Play out the entire college football season with PFSN's CFB Playoff Predictor to see what it means for conference standings and the CFB playoffs!

Former NFL Scout Predicts Carson Beck Draft Night Slide

During Monday’s segment of the “Colin Cowherd” podcast, former Philadelphia Eagles scout John Middlekauff predicted that Beck would slide to the third day of the NFL Draft and that the Canes would do better next season with an upgrade in the quarterback position.

“I think the next step for them, because they’re going to recruit the best defensive and offensive linemen, Mario’s gonna do that at the Saban (Nick) – Smart (Kirby) level,” Middlekauf said. “To me, there was a big difference last year when they had Cam Ward and their offense was super electric. And this year, Carson’s not that level of talent.

“He’ll be drafted on the third day of the draft. Which you have an NFL QB in your offense, you’re gonna be solid. But if they can nail a first-round pick to be their quarterback, they will recruit running backs, they’ll have an offensive line, they should be the toast of the ACC.”

Despite being part of two national championship-winning teams during his polarizing career, Beck finished his college football career with 32 interceptions, most of them coming during crucial moments in games.

Beck Trait Compared to Josh Allen

During Monday’s segment of the “4th&1” podcast, former NFL quarterback Cam Newton gave a damning assessment of Beck’s abilities while comparing him to Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen.

“Don’t tell me you’re a great quarterback in the first quarter, second quarter and third quarter, and all of a sudden in the fourth quarter, when we need you to lock in the most, you’re not great,” Newton said.

“For the most part, consistently, Carson Beck hasn’t shown that. That doesn’t make him a bad player. Like I was saying about Josh Allen today. He’s just not clutch.”

Beck finished his sole season in Coral Gables after transferring from Athens with 3,813 passing yards, resulting in 30 touchdowns and 12 interceptions, while adding 43 rushing yards and 2 touchdowns, and earning himself a PFSN’s CFB QB Impact Metric of 83.3.

More CFB Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More CFB Articles

Alabama Transfer Isaiah Horton Reveals Why He Trusts Marcel Reed at Texas A&M

Wide receiver Isaiah Horton stated that the reason for his transfer from Alabama to Texas A&M was quarterback Marcel Reed.

Curt Cignetti Fires Back at Sonny Dykes Over Josh Hoover ‘Turnover’ Comments

Curt Cignetti defends QB Josh Hoover after Sonny Dykes’ critique, pointing to Indiana’s strong system as key to unlocking his full potential.

D’Angelo Ponds Pro Day 40 Time Shatters Expectations for Projected 2nd-Rounder

D’Angelo Ponds stunned at Indiana’s pro day with blazing 40-yard dash, boosting his 2026 NFL Draft stock and emerging as a rising defensive prospect.