Bryce Underwood Faces Scrutiny for ‘Underwhelming’ Trait After Michigan Setback

CFB Analyst broke down some of Michigan Wolverines quarterback Bryce Underwood's weaknesses from last season.

Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood opted to remain in Ann Arbor despite the controversies surrounding the Wolverines’ coaching situation in December. Underwood distinguished himself as former coach Sherrone Moore’s starter as a freshman and flashed some of the ability that led to him being ranked the No. 1 QB in the class of 2025.

PFSN 2026-2027 CFB Playoff Predictor
Play out the entire college football season with PFSN's CFB Playoff Predictor to see what it means for conference standings and the CFB playoffs!

How Did One Analyst Detail Michigan QB Bryce Underwood’s Weaknesses?

Underwood will work under new quarterbacks coach and offensive coordinator Jason Beck next season as he aims to return the Wolverines to elite status in college football.

During Tuesday’s segment of the “Crain & Cone” podcast, analyst David Pollack scrutinized some of Underwood’s weaknesses from his sole season in college football, while revealing the traits that the quarterback needs to polish.

“I would like to see Bryce Underwood more, but like I was underwhelmed with what I saw from Bryce Underwood this year,” Pollack said. “I was underwhelmed from a standpoint of feet, and as the season went on, he continued to make mistakes in big moments that I’m like, ‘Settle your feet. Make the throw a little bit easier.

“‘You don’t have to throw a checkdown seven thousand miles an hour. We can put a little bit of touch, we can layer the football, like he’s gotta take a big step forward. I love the wheels, I love the size, I love the talent. I was underwhelmed just from the hype. From being the No. 1 QB in the class and making more than all of us in one season.”

RELATED: CFB Transfer Portal Tracker

In 13 games played last season, Underwood tallied 2,428 passing yards on 60.3% completion, resulting in 11 touchdowns and 9 interceptions, while adding 392 rushing yards on 88 carries, resulting in 6 touchdowns.

Kirk Herbstreit Predicts Underwood’s Improvement

During Monday’s segment of the “Crain & Cone” podcast, ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit predicted that Underwood would improve massively next season, while highlighting the issues that limited him last season.

“I think he’s going to have a massive jump, you would expect,” Herbstreit said. “There are times when, if you’re just evaluating him, you have to be careful of just walking away with really concrete thoughts of a guy that’s playing as an 18-year-old and an offense that would take two steps forward, one step back.

“They didn’t really have any receivers. I think he’s going to kind of take off this offseason. I think they’re going to have an offseason to study him and where his sweetspot is, where he can really play well.”

Despite the issues that the Wolverines faced last season, Underwood still led one of the youngest teams in college football to a 9-4 season as a freshman starter, earning a PFSN College QB Impact score of 78.

More CFB Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More CFB Articles

‘They’ve Just Had His Number’ — CFB Analyst Reveals Georgia HC Kirby Smart’s Toughest Road Game in 2026 Season

Georgia fans are most worried about Ole Miss, but Rusty Mansell explains why Alabama still remains Kirby Smart's biggest road challenge in 2026.

‘Cannot Wait To See That Guy’ — LSU LB Puts ‘Special’ Sam Leavitt in Same Category As Jayden Daniels, Garrett Nussmeier

LSU LB Whit Weeks is excited after watching Sam Leavitt at practice, comparing the transfer QB to Jayden Daniels and Garrett Nussmeier.

‘There Should Be a Freshman or Rookie Cap’ — LSU HC Lane Kiffin Floats Bold NIL Fix To Curb Inflated Paychecks

LSU Tigers coach Lane Kiffin called for a freshman salary cap to balance the soaring payments commanded by high school prospects.