When top NFL Draft prospects sit down with team executives and coaches, the evaluations often go far beyond the X’s and O’s. Franchises want to gauge a player’s competitive drive, personality, and how they handle high-pressure situations.
For highly touted Ohio State safety Caleb Downs, his pre-draft visit with the Dallas Cowboys featured a memorable, and slightly competitive, exchange with head coach Brian Schottenheimer that left the coach a little heated.
Top Prospect Caleb Downs Admits He Got Under Brian Schottenheimer’s Skin
As it turns out, the battleground wasn’t the film room or the whiteboard. It was the putting green inside the coach’s office. He recently told Kay Adams from “Up and Adams” that golf was meant to be a way for him to bond with the head coach.
Speaking about his top-30 pre-draft visit with Dallas, Downs shared a hilarious anecdote about his interaction with Schottenheimer. Armed with quiet confidence, the star defensive back didn’t just talk football; he challenged the coach to a putting contest and walked away victorious.
“Coach Schottenheimer, he he won’t like me saying this, but I’ve beat him in putting in his office,” Downs revealed with a smile. “He he got mad about that a little bit. So, I’m a little bit of a golfer, so I beat him at that.”
The story provides a perfect glimpse into the natural swagger and competitive edge that make Downs one of the most elite players in the 2026 NFL Draft class. It takes a certain level of poise to walk into a Dallas Cowboys pre-draft meeting and beat a veteran coach at his own office game. But for Downs, stepping up to the challenge is nothing new.
According to the PFSN, Downs is the unquestioned No. 1 safety in this draft class and the No. 2 overall prospect on their Big Board. Highlighting his dominance at the collegiate level, he boasts an outstanding PFSN CFB Safety Impact Metric score of 93.39.
While navigating the complex landscape of college football, transitioning from a standout true freshman year at Alabama to becoming a championship-caliber centerpiece for Ohio State, Downs has consistently proven his blue-chip status.
His PFSN draft profile paints the picture of a generational, defense-altering talent. Measuring in at 5’11 5/8″ and 206 pounds, Downs is praised for his cosmic football IQ and extraordinary processing speed, earning a near-perfect 9.6 rating in that category. He also boasts exceptional marks in run support (9.3), physicality (9.2), and technique (9.1).
Whether he is lined up in the box as a rover, playing single-high, or transitioning seamlessly into off-man coverage, he is the consummate “glue guy” for any defense. His rare blend of hip fluidity, explosiveness, and unmatched instincts all point toward a future All-Pro career.
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s Ultimate GM Simulator
As the draft approaches, it is clear why the Cowboys brought him in for a top-30 visit. Dallas is always on the hunt for transcendent defensive playmakers, and Downs fits the bill perfectly.
While Schottenheimer might still be recovering from his office putting defeat, there is no doubt the Cowboys, and every other NFL team, would love to have Downs’ winning mentality on their sideline on Sundays.
