The Buffalo Bills’ decision to keep Ed Oliver’s family tragedy private was not an accident, according to beat writer Matt Parrino. It was the result of a deliberate ethical choice.
Parrino pushed back on podcaster Tony Farmer, who first made the story public and later criticized Buffalo reporters for not reporting it sooner. Parrino said the decision was bigger than one reporter deciding whether to chase a scoop.
Matt Parrino Defends Bills Reporters’ Decision
“The person who ‘broke’ this story,” Parrino wrote, referring to Farmer, “puffs his chest out on this app as if he’s the all-knowing journalism ethics grand master.”
Parrino added that “there’s irony in his hubris,” while accusing Farmer of making what he described as “inexcusable errors by journalist standards.”
Parrino then explained the process behind his own decision. He said he spoke in confidence with 21 people he trusted, including colleagues, former editors, and friends, because he did not believe his own opinion was enough when dealing with such a sensitive situation.
“I need to be challenged on my own opinions and be open to the idea that I may not have it entirely right,” Parrino wrote. “That’s journalism. Seeking truth but minimizing harm.”
The person who “broke” this story (I use the term loosely because there were inexcusable errors by journalist standards), puffs his chest out on this app as if he’s the all-knowing journalism ethics grand master.
There’s irony in his hubris considering I’ve done this job in… — Matt Parrino (@MattParrino) August 23, 2026
He said Oliver reported for the first day of training camp roughly a month after the death of his two-year-old son and argued that basic humanity had to outweigh the desire to be first.
“I believe not reporting on Ed’s personal tragedy was the right decision,” Parrino wrote.
START PREPARING: PFN’s Free Fantasy Draft Simulator
Josh Allen Also Thanked Reporters Who Protected Oliver’s Privacy
Parrino’s defense echoed Allen’s criticism after Buffalo’s 31-7 preseason win over Cleveland on Saturday.
Allen thanked reporters who already knew about the tragedy and allowed Oliver and his family to handle it on their own timeline. He said the way the information eventually became public made him “very sad and angry,” while emphasizing that Buffalo’s focus was on supporting Oliver.
BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM: PFN’s Free NFL Mock Draft Simulator
The Bills also issued a team statement expressing condolences to Oliver and his family. General manager Brandon Beane called the loss an “unthinkable tragedy for any parent” and said the organization would continue supporting the family.
Farmer had publicly questioned why the Bills’ reporters did not reveal the situation earlier, describing the lack of coverage as a “media blackout.” That framing became a major part of the backlash.
Parrino’s response offered a direct answer. He was not claiming that reporters simply missed the story, but was saying that some knew enough to report it and consciously decided that publishing it would cause more harm than withholding it.
That distinction has become the heart of the dispute. Farmer viewed the silence as a journalistic failure, whereas Parrino viewed it as journalism working exactly as it should in a situation where being first was far less important than being human.
