The NFL’s annual team report cards have always read a little like a high school honor roll crossed with a corporate performance review, except the students were 300-pound linemen and franchise quarterbacks, and the administrators being graded were billionaires.
However, the tradition is changing.
An arbitrator has ruled in favor of the league in its grievance against the NFL Players Association, ordering the union to stop publicly releasing its annual team report cards.
NFLPA Says ‘Program Is Not Going Away’ After Decision Leads to Backlash
The decision led to arguments that a transparent accountability tool in professional sports has just been quietly benched.
Every season, NFL players are asked to evaluate their workplace, the ecosystem that shapes their daily lives during the season. They grade their teams on ownership, head coaches, training staff, locker room conditions, travel accommodations, weight rooms, nutrition programs, and even how their families are treated.
It’s less about X’s and O’s and more about whether the people cashing the checks are investing in the humans wearing the helmets.
The NFLPA compiles those responses, assigns letter grades, ranks all 32 teams from first to worst, and releases the findings publicly. And the public part? That’s where the pressure lived.
DRAFT SEASON: PFSN’s FREE Mock Draft Simulator
Facilities were upgraded. Staffing decisions reevaluated. Nutrition programs improved. Teams that landed near the bottom often responded with visible, sometimes expensive, changes the following year.
However, the visibility is now gone.
According to a report by Adam Schefter, the NFL informed all 32 franchises that it prevailed in its grievance arguing the public release of the report cards violated the CBA. The league pointed to constitutional provisions barring players from publicly criticizing member clubs or team personnel.
An arbitrator ultimately agreed that while the NFLPA may survey players, it may no longer publish the results.
Prominent reporters questioned the decision. Players past and present voiced reprovals. The underlying argument felt simple: if players can be ranked, and critiqued on national television every Sunday night, why can’t they publicly grade the workplace they show up to every day?
As criticism grew, the NFLPA responded in a statement on Friday, saying that the ruling was not a blanket validation of the league’s broader claims about the process.
The union said the arbitrator rejected the NFL’s attack on the methodology, finding the report cards to be “fair, balanced, and increasingly positive over time.”
BE AN NFL GM: PFSN’s FREE Ultimate GM Simulator
Basically, it made clear that the program itself will continue, just without the megaphone. “The program is not going away,” the statement read, saying that players will still get the results and team management will continue hearing directly from their locker rooms.
NFLPA statement on team report cards: pic.twitter.com/RvMid3sfxr
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) February 13, 2026
Nevertheless, the reproval from around the league comes because of how influential the rankings had become. In the most recent edition, the Miami Dolphins were crowned the league’s top organization, while the Arizona Cardinals finished last, distinctions that fueled offseason conversations and, in some cases, tangible change.
Now, those conversations move behind closed doors.
