Paul Finebaum Disagrees With Clemson’s Position on Coaches’ Poll, But Still Isn’t Convinced of Major Success

Paul Finebaum thinks Clemson is underrated in the coaches poll but still has doubts about how far the Tigers can go in 2025.

Heading into the 2025 season, there is growing buzz around the Clemson Tigers. With senior quarterback Cade Klubnik returning, strong weapons on offense, and a standout defense, Clemson has the pieces to contend for a national title.

In the first coaches’ poll of 2025, the Tigers were ranked in the top ten. While that is a strong ranking, ESPN’s Paul Finebaum believes Clemson is still underrated, though he remains unconvinced they will finish as one of the top teams in the country this season.

PFSN 2026-2027 CFB Playoff Predictor
Play out the entire college football season with PFSN's CFB Playoff Predictor to see what it means for conference standings and the CFB playoffs!

Paul Finebaum Says Clemson Is Underrated, But Still Has Doubts

The Tigers finished 2024 with a strong season, winning the ACC championship and earning a spot in the College Football Playoff. Although they lost their first playoff game against Texas, they return a lot of talent and are expected to be one of the nation’s best teams in 2025.

The preseason coaches’ poll reflected Clemson’s high expectations, ranking the Tigers as the sixth-best team heading into the season.

While that is already a strong position, ESPN analyst Heather Dinich said on “Get Up” that Clemson deserves to be ranked even higher.

Paul Finebaum agreed that the No. 6 ranking might be a little low, but he still expressed doubts about the Tigers based on their performance against non-conference opponents in 2024.

“Clemson is outstanding, I think they are underrated,” Finebaum said. “The problem is, Clemson, they lost to Georgia badly at the beginning of last year, they lost at home to South Carolina, they looked average in their playoff game, so it’s hard to wrap one’s arm around them right now.”

On one hand, Finebaum makes a valid point. While Clemson looked strong in ACC play, they did struggle against some of the top teams in the country last season.

On the other hand, this is a new year, and the Tigers return more production than any other team in the nation, with over 80 percent coming back.

Clemson has one of the best quarterbacks in the country in Klubnik, who is widely projected to be a top ten pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. The Tigers also have a strong offensive line and a deep receiver group led by Antoino Williams, one of the top wideouts in college football.

Defensively, they might be even better. Clemson could have the best defensive end and tackle duo in the country with T.J. Parker and Peter Woods. The secondary is also stacked with talent, led by Avieion Terrell, another projected high draft pick.

The good news for Clemson fans is that a lot will be revealed early in the season. The Tigers open against SEC powerhouse LSU on August 30. A win in that game would be a strong statement that this is not the same Clemson team from a year ago.

More CFB Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More CFB Articles

‘Really Tough Schedule’ — Shane Beamer Stares at Darkness As South Carolina Season Is Already Doomed

For South Carolina head coach Shane Beamer, the 2026 season is rapidly beginning to look like a death march. Despite an offseason fueled by...

‘It Hasn’t Worked’ — Roman Harper Sends Brutal Warning to Alabama About Kalen DeBoer

The ghost of Nick Saban continues to loom large over Tuscaloosa. Despite the Kalen DeBoer era’s fair share of excitement, a sobering reality check...

‘Not the Favorite’ — Why Arch Manning Is Already Falling Behind Trinidad Chambliss in 2026 Heisman Race

After showing glimpses of brilliance toward the second half of the 2025 season, the Arch Manning hype is brewing. As a result, he is...