Facebook Pixel

    Jimmy Garoppolo Trade Value: What sort of value could he provide a new team?

    Rumors are circling regarding a potential trade of Jimmy Garoppolo. Did he provide enough value last season to make him worth it?

    This past season, Jimmy Garoppolo took the San Francisco 49ers to the NFC Championship Game. However, there are rumors that he might have played his last snaps in San Francisco. Let’s look at the advanced metrics to see if trading Garoppolo would be a wise decision, and examine what sort of value he could provide to his new team following a trade.

    Jimmy Garoppolo had an excellent box score this season

    Looking purely at his box score, it would seem that 2021 was one of the better seasons of Garoppolo’s career. Of course, it was also only the second season in which he started more than 10 games, but let’s set that aside for now. During the regular season, he totaled 3,810 yards, 20 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions.

    None of those numbers ranked particularly highly, but it’s here that we must return to the number of games Garoppolo played. While he did start more games last season than in almost any other in his career, he still missed several weeks. As such, his regular-season statistics could have been better.

    Statistics fell off in the playoffs

    Although Garoppolo had a strong regular season, he didn’t keep that up during the playoffs. The 49ers made a surprisingly deep run, but it’s tough to give Garoppolo too much credit for their success. Across three playoff games, Garoppolo threw for 553 yards, 2 touchdowns, and 3 interceptions.

    Most of those numbers came in his last game of the season. During that loss against the Los Angeles Rams, he threw for 232 yards, both of his touchdowns, and an interception. Garoppolo really fell apart when his team needed him most, which isn’t great for his potential trade value.

    Using advanced metrics to see how valuable Garoppolo was last season

    Injuries have kept Garoppolo from reaching his full potential on many occasions, and that was true again in 2021. Fortunately, we can turn to the Offensive Value Metric (OVM) to help us measure his impact on San Francisco’s offense.

    The OVM is a grading system created by the (Bx) Movement to evaluate players based on how much of their statistical production they were actually responsible for.

    This past season, Garoppolo earned an OVM grade of 24.94, which ranked seventh in the NFL among qualifying quarterbacks. That is an exceptionally impressive performance, and it looks even better when you consider how much of a dramatic improvement it was over the year prior.

    Although he missed much of the year, he underperformed significantly when he was on the field, earning the second-worst grade at his position, at 13.52.

    Garoppolo’s improvement likely had something to do with his better health. That said, it’s still a good sign for his future prospects.

    The advanced metrics behind Garoppolo’s grades

    To see why the OVM gave Garoppolo a better grade during this season than the last, we need to look at the numbers involved in calculating those grades. Unsurprisingly, Garoppolo improved in multiple areas. To start with, he threw into tight windows 2% more frequently, at 15.6% compared to 13.6%.

    He also threw the ball significantly further downfield, averaging 7.4 yards compared to 6.2 yards. His completions improved even more dramatically, rising by a full 2 yards, from 3.9 yards to 5.9.

    In comparison, the change in Garoppolo’s completion statistics doesn’t seem all that impressive. His completion rate only rose by a relatively small amount, a little over one percent, from 67.1% to 68.3%.

    However, the real change was in how he played relative to the NFL’s projections. His completion rate went from being 3.6% lower than expected to 1.2% higher.

    Taking all those statistics together and the reason for Garoppolo’s OVM improvement becomes clear: he attempted significantly more difficult passes but still completed more of his attempts this season.

    Examining the variation of his grades across the season

    To help better grasp how Garoppolo has played in the last two years, let’s look at his weekly grades from each of the previous two seasons. You can see them in the chart below, marked by the black dots. For comparison, the average grade for quarterbacks from each season is represented by the yellow line.

    Jimmy Garoppolo Trade Value: What sort of value could he provide a new team?

    Jimmy Garoppolo Trade Value: What sort of value could he provide a new team?

    These charts reveal some interesting patterns. The difference between the two seasons should be obvious. In 2020, Garoppolo earned four grades below 20 points and two below 10, including an abysmal low of 2.84 in Week 5. In 2021, more of his grades were above the average than not. However, the trend within those grades also provides a significant cause for concern.

    Garoppolo had a strong stretch in the middle of the season but was on a steady decline going into the playoffs. Then, as his box score would suggest, Garoppolo played some of his worst football in the playoffs. He ended the year with his worst game of the season, at 5.49.

    Garoppolo’s high overall grade still provides reasons for optimism. But his low-impact performances in key games do temper that rather significantly.

    Should a team trade for Garoppolo?

    During the 2021 season, Garoppolo proved once again that he can take a great team far into the playoffs. And when looking at San Francisco’s season overall, he seems to have contributed heavily to their success.

    However, the statistics also show that he wasn’t the driving force in their offense late in the season. There will definitely be teams who are unwilling to trade significant assets for him because of that flaw. Their concerns will likely be heightened by the real risk that injuries could once again sideline Garoppolo.

    Even so, Garoppolo has seen more success than many quarterbacks do across their entire careers, and teams have won Super Bowls with far worse players leading their offenses. A franchise with a lot of talent on their roster and desperate need of a quarterback, such as the Indianapolis Colts, might look at Garoppolo as their best option.

    Listen to the PFN Inside Access Podcast!

    Listen to the PFN Inside Access Podcast! Click the embedded player below to listen, or you can find the PFN Fantasy Podcast on iTunes, Spotify, and all major podcast platforms.  Be sure to subscribe and leave us a five-star review!

    Related Articles