Fantasy football managers are always on the lookout for hidden gems who can provide an edge during the season. When a lesser-known wide receiver finds the end zone, it naturally sparks questions about waiver wire value. The challenge is figuring out if that performance signals future opportunity or just a one-off highlight. Tory Horton fits that conversation in Week 4, but his role remains limited.
Should Tory Horton Be a Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Add in Week 4?
Rostered: 2%
Basically, anytime a wide receiver scores a touchdown, fantasy managers will be wondering if they should add him. Tory Horton caught one and had a second on a punt return.
Unfortunately, he still only earned four targets and remains the clear third option behind Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Cooper Kupp.
TORY HORTON GOES 95 YARDS TO THE CRIB!
NOvsSEA on CBS/Paramount+https://t.co/HkKw7uXVnt pic.twitter.com/nwjvDYnnD2
— NFL (@NFL) September 21, 2025
Horton is probably not worth adding, as he will need an injury in front of him to matter. Sam Darnold is playing reasonably well, but he cannot support three fantasy-relevant receivers.
Aggressiveness Rating: 1.0
Evaluating Tory Horton as a Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Pickup
When evaluating Horton’s situation, the most important factor remains his place in the depth chart. Four targets are not enough to suggest reliable usage, and touchdown production alone rarely sustains fantasy value. While the punt return score was impressive, it does not carry over to fantasy formats in most leagues. Managers need to keep in mind that Horton is still firmly behind Smith-Njigba and Kupp in the pecking order.
Darnold has been steady enough to keep the offense moving, but there is a clear ceiling on how many receivers he can support in fantasy football. With two established options already commanding consistent looks, Horton’s path to relevance would require injuries or a major shift in scheme. Until either of those scenarios plays out, his role will remain too inconsistent for weekly lineups.
It is natural for fantasy football managers to chase touchdowns on the waiver wire, especially from young wideouts who flash in limited action. However, chasing production without volume is often a recipe for wasted roster spots. The wide receiver pool across the league is deep, and players with more consistent usage are likely to be available.
In the end, Horton is more of a name to monitor than a priority add in Week 4. His talent is evident, but fantasy managers cannot rely on splash plays without the security of targets. Unless something changes in front of him, he is not worth burning waiver priority or spending significant FAAB. Keep him on the watch list, but look elsewhere for immediate help this week.
