NFL Head Coach Rankings 2023: Where Do Andy Reid, Bill Belichick, Matt Eberflus, and Others Land?

Who are the best NFL head coaches? The Bill Belichick and Andy Reid battle continues, as it does for John Harbaugh and Mike Tomlin. What surprises linger?

The best NFL coaches are the ones who know how to take advantage of rules, personnel, and schemes. But no coach is perfect. Each one has their flaws, including the greatest of all time, which showed a season ago.

Who are the best coaches in 2023? Let’s start at the top, where the HC that won  Super Bowl still resides.

Who’s the Best Head Coach in the NFL?

Andy Reid is the best head coach in our NFL Power Rankings. Reid now has two Lombardi trophies and the best collection of Aloha button-ups in the continental U.S.

Patrick Mahomes is a cheat code, and Reid was already arguably the best offensive mind in the game before drafting an alien to play QB for him.

And although Bill Belichick remains the greatest ever, his sins from a season ago have not yet been forgiven nor forgotten.

Head Coach Rankings 2-10

2) Bill Belichick, New England Patriots

Regular-season record: 300-159 (.654)

Despite Belichick’s decision to hire Matt Patricia as offensive coordinator and Joe Judge as the QB coach last season, there’s no denying his ability to coach. He wakes up in the morning able to grow a top-five defense out of thin air, and even though he had the greatest quarterback ever on his side, it is impossible to argue with six championships.

Hiring Bill O’Brien to right the offensive ship was a step in the right direction, but it hasn’t helped that much this season. Mac Jones still doesn’t look like an NFL quarterback most weeks, while New England’s offense ranks 29th in yards per play.

3) John Harbaugh, Baltimore Ravens

Regular-season record: 154-97 (.614)

The only thing that has slowed down the Baltimore Ravens recently has been their horrendous injury luck. They’ve still been to the playoffs in three of the last four seasons, and the roster is contending in a top-heavy AFC again in 2023.

4) Mike Tomlin, Pittsburgh Steelers

Regular-season record: 468-96-2 (.635)

Mike Tomlin and the Pittsburgh Steelers organization are the best in football. Tomlin has cemented his status as an elite football coach, particularly over the past few seasons. Underwhelming rosters haven’t been enough to erase his streak of seasons without a losing record.

Ben Roethlisberger’s arm was Jell-O at the end of his career, the offensive line had dissolved, and none of it mattered because the Steelers simply refused to be bad. They’re perpetual overachievers, and that simply comes down to luck and coaching.

5) Sean McVay, Los Angeles Rams

Regular-season record: 63-44 (.589)

Sean McVay can still work wonders, but given his dalliances with retirement, there will always be questions about how long he intends to remain on the sidelines. He’s also seen his once talented-but-thin roster turn into just a thin roster.

Check out other top positional rankings here: WR | TE | OT | G | DT | EDGE | LB | CB | SK

The Rams’ young roster hasn’t progressed to a competitive point, but young players like WR Puka Nacua and EDGE Byron Young have splashed as rookies, and the elder statesman on the roster are still talented. They could play the spoiler toward the end of the season.

6) Kyle Shanahan, San Francisco 49ers

Regular-season record: 57-49 (.538)

Kyle Shanahan is an emotional head coach who tends to hold grudges against players for minor offenses. But his play-calling, offensive system, and ever-spreading coaching tree are impossible to ignore. He’s a man with many flaws, but his strengths have kept San Francisco relevant with less-than-ideal QB talent for years.

7) Doug Pederson, Jacksonville Jaguars

Regular-season record: 57-47-1 (.548)

The turnaround in Jacksonville was inevitable. Urban Meyer left them a jumbled mess that could only improve. But Doug Pederson completely flipped the culture upon his arrival, and by the end of the season, the Jaguars were a legitimate contender in the playoffs against Mahomes, Reid, and the Chiefs.

Pederson is one of the league’s best play-callers and is also an outstanding leader of men. He also happened to win a Super Bowl against Tom Brady with Nick Foles as his starting quarterback. It’s always nice to see when two parting sides land on their feet, and that’s exactly what happened with the Eagles and Pederson after his departure.

8) Nick Sirianni, Philadelphia Eagles

Regular-season record: 31-12 (.721)

Nick Sirianni is the perfect head coach for the city of Philadelphia. In another life, Sirianni was or will be the best heel in professional wrestling. You could say he missed his calling, but Sirianni is fine coaching football.

Being a great coach is oftentimes about hiring the right people. Since arriving in Philadelphia unceremoniously, particularly after an… interesting… introductory press conference, he’s hired all the right people. Hiring Brian Johnson to work closely with Jalen Hurts as the quarterbacks coach was superb, and elevating him to OC was the correct decision after Shane Steichen left to coach the Colts.

9) Sean McDermott, Buffalo Bills

Regular-season record: 67-39 (.632)

Sean McDermott is one of the few modern defensive coaches to find success at the NFL level. Everyone above him is either an offensive-minded coach or has been at the helm long enough that their careers can legally drink in most countries worldwide.

Playoff success never comes easy. The 2021 Divisional Round is living proof of that. Even 13 seconds was too much time on the clock for Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs. But McDermott and the Bills have parried every attack from the AFC East in recent seasons.

10) Pete Carroll, Seattle Seahawks

Regular-season record: 166-115-1 (.590)

Pete Carroll is special. Along with an army of defensive geniuses, he revolutionized how NFL defenses played. He helped create the Legion of Boom. Then, at 70, he completely changed his philosophies. He’s living proof that you can teach an old dog new tricks.

But for Carroll, age is just a number. He can take the field and legitimately run with his players. Maybe there’s something special in his gum. Or maybe chewing incessantly keeps the body younger somehow. Whatever his secret is, we all want to know it.

Top Head Coaches Remaining

11) Mike McDaniel, Miami Dolphins

Regular-season record: 15-11 (.577)

Mike McDaniel is the ultimate dichotomy. He’s got the look of an IT specialist but is arguably the coolest coach in the sport. He was the 49ers’ run game specialist, but he had the Dolphins’ passing attack looking like the ’84 Dolphins for a while.

He’s new, and he’s cool. But with so little experience, it’s impossible to determine if he’s a great coach yet. But hiring Vic Fangio to man the defensive responsibility was an elite move even if the returns haven’t quite been felt yet.

As of today, Fangio’s subdued defensive philosophy clashes with the Dolphins’ high-powered offense, which should be trying to get as many possessions through the course of a game as possible.

12) Matt LaFleur, Green Bay Packers

Regular-season record: 50-24 (.676)

Matt LaFleur’s .671 winning percentage is third-best among active NFL head coaches, but how much of his success is owed to Aaron Rodgers remains an open question. How LaFleur develops Jordan Love and navigates the next chapter of Packers history will ultimately determine his legacy.

13) Brian Daboll, New York Giants

Regular-season record: 11-14-1 (.460)

Brian Daboll won Coach of the Year after leading the Giants to a playoff appearance, shattering expectations for a team that many thought would be in line for another top-10 draft pick. But New York has struggled to a 2-6 mark, as injuries and ineffectiveness have ruined their chances at another postseason berth.

Daboll’s best trait may be his understanding of the modern NFL game and the importance of the QB run. However, hiring is an important part of coaching, and gathering a staff of Mike Kafka and Wink Martindale was an outstanding decision.

Unfortunately, the Giants’ offensive line has disintegrated through injuries, and their offense has absolutely no juice at the moment. Daniel Jones returned from an injury but tore his ACL on a dropback early in their game against the Raiders.

14) Mike McCarthy, Dallas Cowboys

Regular-season record: 160-100-2 (.615)

Mike McCarthy might catapult the Dallas Cowboys to heights they haven’t reached in literal decades. That is not something anyone expected when they announced his hiring.

The Cowboys are leaning on analytics, using more than just the NFL Draft to build their roster, and McCarthy has hired arguably the best coaching staff in the NFL with Dan Quinn and John “Bones” Fossel.

15) Sean Payton, Denver Broncos

Regular-season record: 155-94 (.622)

The 2023 NFL season could be the first true indication of how good a coach Sean Payton is or is not. He only spent one season as the Saints head coach without Drew Brees.

However, in Payton’s one-year absence from professional football in 2012, the Saints went 7-9. That record was sandwiched between 13 and 11-win seasons, respectively.

16) Zac Taylor, Cincinnati Bengals

Regular-season record: 33-39-1 (.459)

Zac Taylor may or may not be a good head coach. Honestly, the jury is still out. However, he made significant strides in how the offense operates a season ago, and it significantly improved the team.

With Joe Burrow, Ja’Marr Chase, Tee Higgins, Tyler Boyd, and Joe Mixon on the roster, it’s difficult to know for sure if Zac Taylor is an offensive wizard or the product of an unbelievable cast of talent. However, the tactical improvements he made to the offense in 2022 were evidence that he knows what he’s doing.

MORE: Highest-Paid Head Coaches in 2023

They moved nearly their entire offense to the shotgun. They couldn’t run under center because they never passed from it. He also hired Lou Anarumo, which is single-handedly the best decision he’s made as a coach because those defenses are the reason the Bengals have made a few serious postseason runs the past two years.

17) Mike Vrabel, Tennessee Titans

Regular-season record: 51-39 (.567)

What Mike Vrabel accomplished with the 2021 Titans was nothing short of extraordinary. Somehow a team with more injuries (real) than a football team has through the course of their entire season (fake) captured the top seed in the conference. But that luck has run dry.

The personnel side of things has taken a turn for the worse over the past two seasons, and there were whispers that, like his old coach, Vrabel has been trying to seize more control over the roster. That’s spelled disaster for a few Belichick disciples in the past. Does Vrabel have what it takes to prosper where others have failed?

18) Frank Reich, Carolina Panthers

Regular-season record: 41-40-1 (.506)

Frank Reich won a Super Bowl with the Eagles as Pederson’s OC with a heavy dose of RPOs. Bruce Young is one of the best we’ve seen at that operation, and it should be a big part of the Panthers’ offense in 2023.

After being fired by the Colts midway through last season, Reich quickly hopped back onto his feet. His first task was hiring an all-star staff. Adding OC Thomas Brown, DC Ejiro Evero, QBs coach Josh McCown, and RBs coach Duce Staley was about the best he could have hoped for.

19) Dan Campbell, Detroit Lions

Regular-season record: 23-30-1 (.435)

Some football coaches are leaders of men. Tomlin is the first coach to come to mind in that category. Dan Campbell is the second. Campbell has the façade of an old-school knuckle-dragger, but he is aggressive in all the right ways, and his players legitimately appear to love and fight for him.

The “rah-rah” coaches are often present as insincere. But Campbell is a man secure enough to sit at a podium and openly weep after a loss because he legitimately feels for his players.

20) Kevin Stefanski, Cleveland Browns

Regular-season record: 31-27 (.534)

Kevin Stefanski led Cleveland to their first playoff victory since before Princess Diana died. And Stefanski’s offensive philosophy has helped spur the Browns to wins in 2023 despite their quarterback play, whether it be Deshaun Watson or PJ Walker under center.

21) Kevin O’Connell, Minnesota Vikings

Regular-season record: 18-8 (.692)

Kevin O’Connell changed the culture in Minnesota, helping the Vikings move on from the dour atmosphere former head coach Mike Zimmer left behind. But it’s still unclear how good the Vikings are.

With Kirk Cousins now out for the remainder of the 2023 NFL season because of an Achilles injury, O’Connell will have his work cut out for him to bring these Vikings back to the playoffs.

22) Brandon Staley, Los Angeles Chargers

Regular-season record: 23-19 (.548)

Brandon Staley got bullied into being a coward on fourth downs, and we must bully him back into playing the numbers and being aggressive on money downs. But as a defensive-minded coach, blowing a 27-point lead in a playoff game is detrimental to your ranking as a coach.

Kellen Moore is an upgrade from Joe Lombardi, but the offensive roster may still not have enough speed to properly show off Justin Herbert’s supreme skill set. With the Chargers continuing to underperform, Staley might not be on this list much longer at this rate.

23) Arthur Smith, Atlanta Falcons

Regular-season record: 18-25 (.419)

The Falcons’ roster hasn’t been competitive enough to show us whether or not Arthur Smith is a good head coach. It’s impossible to argue with his ability to create an efficient rushing attack, and his play-action passing philosophy allows a decent offensive line to look far more productive than their talent would suggest.

However, Smith has been criminally underusing some of his best talent like TE Kyle Pitts and RB Bijan Robinson. This has caused quite a bit of questions to surface about what Smith is capable of.

24) Robert Saleh, New York Jets

Regular-season record: 15-27 (.357)

Robert Saleh isn’t the general manager and likely was not the main reason why the Jets drafted Zach Wilson. However, that decision still falls partially on him, as does the team’s decision to chase a ring with Aaron Rodgers.

Saleh is in the Campbell and Tomlin mold of being a leader of men, but he is also a very talented defensive coach in his own right. That unit flies to the football like none other in the league, and that secondary is as well-coached as any as well.

Losing Rodgers in the first game of the season was a brutal loss for the team. However, Saleh deserves a ton of credit for keeping this roster competitive.

25) Ron Rivera, Washington Commanders

Regular-season record: 102-95-2 (.518)

Ron Rivera will take his riverboat to retirement someday and wonder if coaching the Commanders while Dan Snyder was the owner was worth the stress. Not many head coaches have to deal with an ownership situation like the Commanders’, and Rivera is excellent at maintaining spirits in Washington.

Time is likely running out on Rivera. Washington’s new ownership group insisted on trading away their two best pass rushers, and the group will likely want to bring in their own guy to run the show after 2023.

26) Todd Bowles, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Regular-season record: 37-55 (.402)

There was some optimism surrounding the Tampa Bay Buccaneers team locally in 2023, but it would take a magical resurgence from Baker Mayfield to keep the ship from capsizing. The roster as a whole doesn’t mimic that of your normal bottom-tier team, but last season and Mayfield’s recent history don’t fill many with optimism.

27) Dennis Allen, New Orleans Saints

Regular-season record: 20-42 (.323)

Derek Carr might be enough to save Dennis Allen’s career as an NFL head coach. But if New Orleans can’t win this NFC South, Allen’s goose is cooked. The Saints are throwing everything they have at the next two seasons, making 2023 a do-or-die (figuratively) situation for Allen.

28) Matt Eberflus, Chicago Bears

Regular-season record: 5-21 (.192)

It’s impossible to know whether Matt Eberflus is head coaching material or if he should have remained a defensive coordinator. The Bears roster was awful a season ago.

MORE: 2023 NFL Offense Rankings | 2023 NFL Defense Rankings

Although Chicago’s roster seemingly improved since last season, the offense and defense have regressed. Additionally, the team seems to lack the necessary fight to compete in football games so far in 2023. Fields’ health has also been quite a concern in 2023.

First-Year Head Coaches

The 2023 NFL season will feature three first-time head coaches on the sidelines. It’s too early to judge them, so we’ll list them alphabetically rather than rank the trifecta.

Jonathan Gannon, Arizona Cardinals

Regular-season record: 1-8 (.111)

Jonathan Gannon doesn’t stand a chance with the Arizona Cardinals unless the organization is willing to give him three full seasons to try and turn things around. His roster is the worst we’ve seen in at least a decade.

DeMeco Ryans, Houston Texans

Regular-season record: 4-4 (.500)

DeMeco Ryans flirted with head coaching opportunities in 2022, but he returned to the Texans, where he starred as a linebacker from 2006-11.

Ryans has added some of “his guys” defensively to bring young talents along, and the team landed their franchise passer in the NFL Draft. It might take time, but things are looking up in Houston.

Shane Steichen, Indianapolis Colts

Regular-season record: 4-5 (.444)

Shane Steichen is the perfect play-caller for rookie QB Anthony Richardson. Unfortunately, Richardson had his first season cut short due to injury. However, the future is bright in Indianapolis and Steichen is continuing to keep this Colts team competitive with Gardner Minshew under center.

Interim Head Coaches

Antonio Pierce, Las Vegas Raiders

The circumstances surrounding Josh McDaniels’ termination are simple. Pierce was the head coach at Long Beach Poly High School, but that is the only time he’s called the shots. His other coaching opportunities were as the linebackers coach at Arizona State, which led to a defensive coordinator role after just one season.

Although this experience likely won’t result in a long-term head coaching opportunity with the Raiders because of his inexperience, it’s a great experience, and the Raiders’ players seem keen on him.

Want to predict the rest of the 2023 season with our FREE NFL Playoff Predictor? Looking for the most up-to-date NFL standings? What about a breakdown of team depth charts or the NFL schedule? Pro Football Network has you covered with that and more! 

Listen to the PFN Inside Access Podcast!

Listen to the PFN Inside Access Podcast! Click the embedded player below to listen, or you can find the PFN Fantasy Podcast on iTunes, Spotify, and all major podcast platforms.  Be sure to subscribe and leave us a five-star review!

Join the Conversation!

Related Articles