This week, ESPN analyst Monica McNutt has been all over the headlines. She had already faced criticism after saying Caitlin Clark needed more “accountability and self-awareness” about “her role in the larger sisterhood” within the WNBA.
Then, another moment pushed McNutt into the spotlight. During a recent appearance on ESPN’s “SportsCenter,” she joined the broadcast while sitting in a beauty salon chair and getting a manicure. Some viewers quickly criticized the setting instead of her analysis.
However, former ESPN personality Jemele Hill defended McNutt and, in doing so, shifted the attention toward Pat McAfee’s past on-air behavior.
Jemele Hill Defended Monica McNutt’s Recent On-Air Incident While Calling Out Pat McAfee
Hill questioned the different standards applied to the two media personalities.
“So let me get this straight: Pat McAfee can hit a vape during a broadcast and openly admit he smokes a lot of weed, but y’all on here losing your minds about Monica McNutt’s pedicure,” Hill wrote on X. “Yeah, ok. And also: I do not care that McAfee did either. It’s the hypocrisy for me.”
Her post quickly gained traction because it directly challenged what she viewed as inconsistent public outrage.
McAfee’s viral moment came during the 2025 NFL Draft in Green Bay. While hosting his “Draft Spectacular,” McAfee was vaping on the live broadcast. He also offered the vape pen to former Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy, who immediately declined before the show continued.
BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM: PFN’s FREE NFL Mock Draft Simulator
However, later, McAfee addressed the incident. He explained that the fan had handed him the vape pen just before the broadcast started. According to McAfee, it contained “CBD/Vitamins,” and he appeared to push back against assumptions that it involved anything else.
Now, coming back to McNutt’s situation, public opinion remains divided over whether appearing from a nail salon during a national television segment crossed a line. Some believe she should have chosen a different location before going on air.
PREDICT THE NFL SEASON: PFN’s FREE NFL Playoff Predictor
Sports analyst Dan Dakich also openly criticized the incident and questioned ESPN’s standards.
“Amazing how much @ESPN has lowered standards,” Dakich said on X.
However, fellow ESPN analyst Kendrick Perkins quickly stepped in to defend McNutt, arguing that many critics were making too much of a routine television appearance instead of focusing on what she actually said.
“So most likely she got asked to a hit that wasn’t on her schedule, and she said yes… and it’s her fault???,” Perkins wrote. “Stop trying to make nothing into something. It’s 2026, and nothing is normal no more.”
For now, the discussion shows no sign of fading. However, from now on, McNutt may avoid similar on-air settings because they are likely to invite another round of criticism that shifts attention away from her analysis.
